Skip to content

OpenMachine-ai/tinyfive

Repository files navigation

TinyFive

Colab Downloads

TinyFive is a lightweight RISC-V emulator and assembler written entirely in Python:

  • TinyFive brings the power of Python and NumPy to assembly code.
  • Useful for running neural networks on RISC-V: Simulate your RISC-V assembly code along with a neural network in Keras or PyTorch (and without relying on RISC-V toolchains).
  • Custom instructions can be added for easy HW/SW codesign in Python (without C++ and compiler toolchains).
  • If you want to learn how RISC-V works, TinyFive lets you play with instructions and assembly code in this colab.
  • TinyFive might also be useful for ML scientists who are using ML/RL for compiler optimizations (see e.g. CompilerGym) or to replace compiler toolchains by AI.
  • Can be very fast if you only use the upper-case instructions defined in the first ~200 lines of machine.py.
  • Fewer than 1000 lines of code (w/o tests and examples)
  • Uses NumPy for math

Contents

Installation

pip install tinyfive

Usage

TinyFive can be used in the following three ways:

  • Option A: Use upper-case instructions such as ADD() and MUL(), see examples 1.1, 1.2, 2.1, and 3.1 below.
  • Option B: Use asm() and exe() functions without branch instructions, see examples 1.3 and 2.2 below.
  • Option C: Use asm() and exe() functions with branch instructions, see example 2.3, 3.2, and 3.3 below.

For the examples below, import and instantiate a RISC-V machine with at least 4KB of memory as follows:

from tinyfive.machine import machine
m = machine(mem_size=4000)  # instantiate RISC-V machine with 4KB of memory

Example 1: Multiply two numbers

Example 1.1: Use upper-case instructions (option A) with back-door loading of registers.

m.x[11] = 6        # manually load '6' into register x[11]
m.x[12] = 7        # manually load '7' into register x[12]
m.MUL(10, 11, 12)  # x[10] := x[11] * x[12]
print(m.x[10])
# Output: 42

Example 1.2: Same as example 1.1, but now load the data from memory. Specifically, the data values are stored at addresses 0 and 4. Here, each value is 32 bits wide (i.e. 4 bytes wide), which occupies 4 addresses in the byte-wide memory.

m.write_i32(6, 0)  # manually write '6' into mem[0] (memory @ address 0)
m.write_i32(7, 4)  # manually write '7' into mem[4] (memory @ address 4)
m.LW (11, 0,  0)   # load register x[11] from mem[0 + 0]
m.LW (12, 4,  0)   # load register x[12] from mem[4 + 0]
m.MUL(10, 11, 12)  # x[10] := x[11] * x[12]
print(m.x[10])
# Output: 42

Example 1.3: Same as example 1.2, but now use asm() and exe() (option B). The assembler function asm() function takes an instruction and converts it into machine code and stores it in memory at address s.pc. Once the entire assembly program is written into memory mem[], the exe() function (aka ISS) can then exectute the machine code stored in memory.

m.write_i32(6, 0)  # manually write '6' into mem[0] (memory @ address 0)
m.write_i32(7, 4)  # manually write '7' into mem[4] (memory @ address 4)

# store assembly program in mem[] starting at address 4*20
m.pc = 4*20
m.asm('lw',  11, 0,  0)   # load register x[11] from mem[0 + 0]
m.asm('lw',  12, 4,  0)   # load register x[12] from mem[4 + 0]
m.asm('mul', 10, 11, 12)  # x[10] := x[11] * x[12]

# execute program from address 4*20: execute 3 instructions and then stop
m.exe(start=4*20, instructions=3)
print(m.x[10])
# Output: 42

Example 2: Add two vectors

We are using the following memory map for adding two 8-element vectors res[] := a[] + b[], where each vector element is 32 bits wide (i.e. each element occupies 4 byte-addresses in memory).

Byte address Contents
0 .. 4*7 a-vector: a[0] is at address 0, a[7] is at address 4*7
4*8 .. 4*15 b-vector: b[0] is at address 4*8, b[7] is at address 4*15
4*16 .. 4*23 result-vector: res[0] is at address 4*16, res[7] is at address 4*23

Example 2.1: Use upper-case instructions (option A) with Python for-loop.

# generate 8-element vectors a[] and b[] and store them in memory
a = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
b = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
m.write_i32_vec(a, 0)    # write vector a[] to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(b, 4*8)  # write vector b[] to mem[4*8]

# pseudo-assembly for adding vectors a[] and b[] using Python for-loop
for i in range(8):
  m.LW (11, 4*i,      0)   # load x[11] with a[i] from mem[4*i + 0]
  m.LW (12, 4*(i+8),  0)   # load x[12] with b[i] from mem[4*(i+8) + 0]
  m.ADD(10, 11,       12)  # x[10] := x[11] + x[12]
  m.SW (10, 4*(i+16), 0)   # store results in mem[], starting at address 4*16

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*16, size=8)  # read result vector from address 4*16
ref = a + b                         # golden reference: simply add a[] + b[]
print(res - ref)                    # print difference (should be all-zero)
# Output: [0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0]

Example 2.2: Same as example 2.1, but now use asm() and exe() functions without branch instructions (option B).

# generate 8-element vectors a[] and b[] and store them in memory
a = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
b = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
m.write_i32_vec(a, 0)    # write vector a[] to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(b, 4*8)  # write vector b[] to mem[4*8]

# store assembly program in mem[] starting at address 4*48
m.pc = 4*48
for i in range(8):
  m.asm('lw',  11, 4*i,      0)   # load x[11] with a[i] from mem[4*i + 0]
  m.asm('lw',  12, 4*(i+8),  0)   # load x[12] with b[i] from mem[4*(i+8) + 0]
  m.asm('add', 10, 11,       12)  # x[10] := x[11] + x[12]
  m.asm('sw',  10, 4*(i+16), 0)   # store results in mem[], starting at address 4*16

# execute program from address 4*48: execute 8*4 instructions and then stop
m.exe(start=4*48, instructions=8*4)

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*16, size=8)  # read result vector from address 4*16
ref = a + b                         # golden reference: simply add a[] + b[]
print(res - ref)                    # print difference (should be all-zero)
# Output: [0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0]

Example 2.3: Same as example 2.2, but now use asm() and exe() functions with branch instructions (option C). The lbl() function defines labels, which are symbolic names that represent memory addresses. These labels improve the readability of branch instructions and mark the start and end of the assembly code executed by the exe() function.

# generate 8-element vectors a[] and b[] and store them in memory
a = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
b = np.random.randint(100, size=8)
m.write_i32_vec(a, 0)    # write vector a[] to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(b, 4*8)  # write vector b[] to mem[4*8]

# store assembly program starting at address 4*48
m.pc = 4*48
# x[13] is the loop-variable that is incremented by 4: 0, 4, .., 28
# x[14] is the constant 28+4 = 32 for detecting the end of the for-loop
m.lbl('start')                 # define label 'start'
m.asm('add',  13, 0, 0)        # x[13] := x[0] + x[0] = 0 (because x[0] is always 0)
m.asm('addi', 14, 0, 32)       # x[14] := x[0] + 32 = 32 (because x[0] is always 0)
m.lbl('loop')                  # label 'loop'
m.asm('lw',   11, 0,    13)    # load x[11] with a[] from mem[0 + x[13]]
m.asm('lw',   12, 4*8,  13)    # load x[12] with b[] from mem[4*8 + x[13]]
m.asm('add',  10, 11,   12)    # x[10] := x[11] + x[12]
m.asm('sw',   10, 4*16, 13)    # store x[10] in mem[4*16 + x[13]]
m.asm('addi', 13, 13,   4)     # x[13] := x[13] + 4 (increment x[13] by 4)
m.asm('bne',  13, 14, 'loop')  # branch to 'loop' if x[13] != x[14]
m.lbl('end')                   # label 'end'

# execute program: start at label 'start', stop when label 'end' is reached
m.exe(start='start', end='end')

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*16, size=8)  # read result vector from address 4*16
ref = a + b                         # golden reference: simply add a[] + b[]
print(res - ref)                    # print difference (should be all-zero)
# Output: [0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0]

A slightly more efficient implementation would decrement the loop variable x[13] (instead of incrementing) so that the branch instruction compares against x[0] = 0 (instead of the constant stored in x[14]), which frees up register x[14] and reduces the total number of instructions by 1.

Use print_perf() to analyze performance and dump_state() to print out the current values of the register files and the the program counter (PC) as follows:

>>> m.print_perf()
Ops counters: {'total': 50, 'load': 16, 'store': 8, 'mul': 0, 'add': 18, 'madd': 0, 'branch': 8}
x[] regfile : 5 out of 31 x-registers are used
f[] regfile : 0 out of 32 f-registers are used
Image size  : 32 Bytes

>>> m.dump_state()
pc   :  224
x[ 0]:    0, x[ 1]:    0, x[ 2]:    0, x[ 3]:    0
x[ 4]:    0, x[ 5]:    0, x[ 6]:    0, x[ 7]:    0
x[ 8]:    0, x[ 9]:    0, x[10]:   34, x[11]:   27
x[12]:    7, x[13]:   32, x[14]:   32, x[15]:    0
x[16]:    0, x[17]:    0, x[18]:    0, x[19]:    0
x[20]:    0, x[21]:    0, x[22]:    0, x[23]:    0
x[24]:    0, x[25]:    0, x[26]:    0, x[27]:    0
x[28]:    0, x[29]:    0, x[30]:    0, x[31]:    0

Example 3: Multiply two matrices

We are using the following memory map for multiplying two 4x4 matrices as res := np.matmul(A, B), where each matrix element is 32 bits wide (i.e. each element occupies 4 byte-addresses in memory).

Byte address Contents
0 .. 4*15 A-matrix in row-major order: A[0, 0], A[0, 1], ... A[3, 3]
4*16 .. 4*31 B-matrix in row-major order: B[i, j] is at address 4*(16+i*4+j)
4*32 .. 4*47 result matrix res[0, 0] ... res[3, 3]

Example 3.1: Use upper-case instructions (option A) with Python for-loop.

# generate 4x4 matrices A and B and store them in memory
A = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
B = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
m.write_i32_vec(A.flatten(), 0)     # write matrix A to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(B.flatten(), 4*16)  # write matrix B to mem[4*16]

# pseudo-assembly for matmul(A, B) using Python for-loops
for i in range(4):
  # load x[10] ... x[13] with row i of A
  for k in range(4):
    m.LW (10+k, 4*(4*i+k), 0)  # load x[10+k] with A[i, k]

  for j in range(4):
    # calculate dot product
    m.LW (18, 4*(16+j), 0)        # load x[18] with B[0, j]
    m.MUL(19, 10, 18)             # x[19] := x[10] * x[18] = A[i, 0] * B[0, j]
    for k in range(1, 4):
      m.LW (18, 4*(16+4*k+j), 0)  # load x[18] with B[k, j]
      m.MUL(18, 10+k, 18)         # x[18] := x[10+k] * x[18] = A[i, k] * B[k, j]
      m.ADD(19, 19, 18)           # x[19] := x[19] + x[18]
    m.SW (19, 4*(32+i*4+j), 0)    # store res[i, j] from x[19]

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*32, size=4*4).reshape(4, 4)  # read result matrix
ref = np.matmul(A, B)            # golden reference
print(np.array_equal(res, ref))  # should return 'True'
# Output: True

Example 3.2: Same as example 3.1, but now use asm() and exe() functions with branch instructions (option C).

# generate 4x4 matrices A and B and store them in memory
A = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
B = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
m.write_i32_vec(A.flatten(), 0)     # write matrix A to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(B.flatten(), 4*16)  # write matrix B to mem[4*16]

# store assembly program starting at address 4*128
m.pc = 4*128
# here, we decrement the loop variables down to 0 so that we don't need an
# additional register to hold the constant for detecting the end of the loop:
#  - x[20] is 4*4*i (i.e. the outer-loop variable) and is decremented by 16 from 64
#  - x[21] is 4*j (i.e. the inner-loop variable) and is decremented by 4 from 16
m.lbl('start')
m.asm('addi', 20, 0, 64)          # x[20] := 0 + 64

m.lbl('outer-loop')
m.asm('addi', 20, 20, -16)        # decrement loop-variable: x[20] := x[20] - 16
m.asm('lw',   10, 0,   20)        # load x[10] with A[i, 0] from mem[0 + x[20]]
m.asm('lw',   11, 4,   20)        # load x[11] with A[i, 1] from mem[4 + x[20]]
m.asm('lw',   12, 2*4, 20)        # load x[12] with A[i, 2] from mem[2*4 + x[20]]
m.asm('lw',   13, 3*4, 20)        # load x[13] with A[i, 3] from mem[3*4 + x[20]]
m.asm('addi', 21, 0, 16)          # reset loop-variable j: x[21] := 0 + 16

m.lbl('inner-loop')
m.asm('addi', 21, 21, -4)         # decrement j: x[21] := x[21] - 4

m.asm('lw',  18, 4*16, 21)        # load x[18] with B[0, j] from mem[4*16 + x[21]]
m.asm('mul', 19, 10, 18)          # x[19] := x[10] * x[18] = A[i, 0] * B[0, j]

m.asm('lw',  18, 4*(16+4), 21)    # load x[18] with B[1, j]
m.asm('mul', 18, 11, 18)          # x[18] := x[11] * x[18] = A[i, 1] * B[1, j]
m.asm('add', 19, 19, 18)          # x[19] := x[19] + x[18]

m.asm('lw',  18, 4*(16+2*4), 21)  # load x[18] with B[2, j]
m.asm('mul', 18, 12, 18)          # x[18] := x[11] * x[18] = A[i, 2] * B[2, j]
m.asm('add', 19, 19, 18)          # x[19] := x[19] + x[18]

m.asm('lw',  18, 4*(16+3*4), 21)  # load x[18] with B[3, j]
m.asm('mul', 18, 13, 18)          # x[18] := x[11] * x[18] = A[i, 3] * B[3, j]
m.asm('add', 19, 19, 18)          # x[19] := x[19] + x[18]

m.asm('add', 24, 20, 21)          # calculate base address for result-matrix
m.asm('sw',  19, 4*32, 24)        # store res[i, j] from x[19]

m.asm('bne', 21, 0, 'inner-loop') # branch to 'inner-loop' if x[21] != 0
m.asm('bne', 20, 0, 'outer-loop') # branch to 'outer-loop' if x[20] != 0
m.lbl('end')

# execute program from 'start' to 'end'
m.exe(start='start', end='end')

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*32, size=4*4).reshape(4, 4)  # read result matrix
ref = np.matmul(A, B)            # golden reference
print(np.array_equal(res, ref))  # should return 'True'
# Output: True

Example 3.3: Same as example 3.2, but now use Python for-loops in the assembly code to improve readability.

# generate 4x4 matrices A and B and store them in memory
A = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
B = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
m.write_i32_vec(A.flatten(), 0)     # write matrix A to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(B.flatten(), 4*16)  # write matrix B to mem[4*16]

# store assembly program starting at address 4*128
m.pc = 4*128
# here, we decrement the loop variables down to 0 so that we don't need an
# additional register to hold the constant for detecting the end of the loop:
#  - x[20] is 4*4*i (i.e. the outer-loop variable) and is decremented by 16 from 64
#  - x[21] is 4*j (i.e. the inner-loop variable) and is decremented by 4 from 16
m.lbl('start')
m.asm('addi', 20, 0, 64)            # x[20] := 0 + 64
m.lbl('outer-loop')
m.asm('addi', 20, 20, -16)          # decrement loop-variable: x[20] := x[20] - 16
for k in range(4):
  m.asm('lw', 10+k, k*4, 20)        # load x[10+k] with A[i, k] from mem[k*4 + x[20]]
m.asm('addi', 21, 0, 16)            # reset loop-variable j: x[21] := 0 + 16
m.lbl('inner-loop')
m.asm('addi', 21, 21, -4)           # decrement j: x[21] := x[21] - 4
m.asm('lw',   18, 4*16, 21)         # load x[18] with B[0, j] from mem[4*16 + x[21]]
m.asm('mul',  19, 10, 18)           # x[19] := x[10] * x[18] = A[i, 0] * B[0, j]
for k in range(1, 4):
  m.asm('lw',  18, 4*(16+k*4), 21)  # load x[18] with B[k, j]
  m.asm('mul', 18, 10+k, 18)        # x[18] := x[10+k] * x[18] = A[i, k] * B[k, j]
  m.asm('add', 19, 19, 18)          # x[19] := x[19] + x[18]
m.asm('add', 24, 20, 21)            # calculate base address for result-matrix
m.asm('sw',  19, 4*32, 24)          # store res[i, j] from x[19]
m.asm('bne', 21, 0, 'inner-loop')   # branch to 'inner-loop' if x[21] != 0
m.asm('bne', 20, 0, 'outer-loop')   # branch to 'outer-loop' if x[20] != 0
m.lbl('end')

# execute program from 'start' to 'end'
m.exe(start='start', end='end')

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*32, size=4*4).reshape(4, 4)  # read result matrix
ref = np.matmul(A, B)            # golden reference
print(np.array_equal(res, ref))  # should return 'True'
# Output: True

Performance numbers for example 3.3:

>>> m.print_perf()
Ops counters: {'total': 269, 'load': 80, 'store': 16, 'mul': 64, 'add': 89, 'madd': 0, 'branch': 20}
x[] regfile : 9 out of 31 x-registers are used
f[] regfile : 0 out of 32 f-registers are used
Image size  : 92 Bytes

Example 3.4: 4x4 matrix multiplication optimized for runtime at the expense of image size and register file usage. Specifically, we first store the entire B matrix in the register file. And we fully unroll the for-loops to eliminate loop variables and branch instructions at the expense of a larger image size.

# generate 4x4 matrices A and B and store them in memory
A = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
B = np.random.randint(100, size=(4, 4))
m.write_i32_vec(A.flatten(), 0)     # write matrix A to mem[0]
m.write_i32_vec(B.flatten(), 4*16)  # write matrix B to mem[4*16]

# store assembly program starting at address 4*128
m.pc = 4*128
m.lbl('start')
# load entire B matrix into registers x[16] ... x[31]
for i in range(4):
  for j in range(4):
    m.asm('lw', 16+4*i+j, 4*(16+4*i+j), 0)
# perform matmul in row-major order
for i in range(4):
  for k in range(4):                    # load x[10] ... x[13] with row i of A
    m.asm('lw', 10+k, 4*(4*i+k), 0)     # load x[10+k] with A[i, k]
  for j in range(4):
    m.asm('mul', 15, 10, 16+j)          # x[15] := x[10] * x[16+j] = A[i, 0] * B[0, j]
    for k in range(1, 4):
      m.asm('mul', 14, 10+k, 16+4*k+j)  # x[14] := x[10+k] * x[16+4k+j] = A[i, k] * B[k, j]
      m.asm('add', 15, 15, 14)          # x[15] := x[15] + x[14]
    m.asm('sw', 15, 4*(32+i*4+j), 0)    # store res[i, j] from x[15]
m.lbl('end')

# execute program from 'start' to 'end'
m.exe(start='start', end='end')

# compare results against golden reference
res = m.read_i32_vec(4*32, size=4*4).reshape(4, 4)  # read result matrix
ref = np.matmul(A, B)            # golden reference
print(np.array_equal(res, ref))  # should return 'True'
# Output: True

The table below shows a speedup of 1.7 with the following caveats:

  • The bit-widths don't make sense for fixed point (in general, multiplying two 32-bit integers produces a 64-bit product; and adding 4 of these products requires up to 66 bits).
  • For runtime calculations, we assume that our RISC-V CPU can only perform one instruction per cycle (while many RISC-V cores can perform multiple instructions per cycle).
  • We assume all 31 registers can be used, which is unrealistic because we ignore register allocation conventions such as the procedure calling conventions specified here.
Image Registers Load Store Mul Add Branch Total ops Speedup
Example 3.3 92B 9 80 16 64 89 20 269 1
Example 3.4 640B 22 32 16 64 48 0 160 1.7

Example 4: Neural network layers

Coming soon, see file layer_examples.py for now

Example 5: MobileNet

Coming soon-ish, see file mobilenet_v1_0.25.py for now

Running in colab

Colab This is the quickest way to get started and should work on any machine.

If you have a free Google Drive account, you can make a copy of this colab via the menu File -> Save a copy in Drive. Now you can edit the code.

Alternatively, start a new colab in your Google Drive as follows: Go here and click on New -> More -> Google Colaboratory. Then copy below lines into your colab:

!pip install tinyfive
from tinyfive.machine import machine
import numpy as np

m = machine(mem_size=4000)  # instantiate RISC-V machine with 4KB of memory

Running without package

If you don't want to use the TinyFive python package, then you can clone the latest repo and install numpy as follows:

git clone https://github.com/OpenMachine-ai/tinyfive.git
cd tinyfive
pip install numpy

To run the examples, type:

python3 examples.py

To run the test suite, type:

python3 tests.py

If you don't want to run above steps on your local machine, you can run it in a colab as follows: Start a new colab in your Google Drive by going here and clicking on New -> More -> Google Colaboratory. Then copy below lines into your colab:

!git clone https://github.com/OpenMachine-ai/tinyfive.git
%cd tinyfive

# run examples
!python3 examples.py

# run test suite
!python3 tests.py

Contribute

If you like this project, give it a ⭐ and share it with friends! And if you are interested in helping make TinyFive better, I highly welcome you to do so. I thank you in advance for your interest. If you are unsure of what you could do to improve the project, you may have a look here.

Latest status

  • TinyFive is still under construction, many things haven't been implemented and tested yet.
  • 37 of the 40 base instructions (RV32I), all instructions of the M-extension (RV32M) and the F-extension (RV32F) with the default rounding mode are already implemented, and many of them are tested. (The three missing RV32I instructions fence, ebreak, and ecall are not applicable here.)
  • Remaining work: improve testing, add more extensions. See TODOs in the code for more details.
  • Stay updated by following us on Twitter, Post.news, and LinkedIn.

Speed

  • TinyFive is not optimized for speed (but for ease-of-use and LOC).
  • You might be able to use PyPy or Codon to speed up TinyFive (see e.g. the Pydgin paper for details).
  • If you only use the upper-case instructions such as ADD(), then TinyFive is very fast because there is no instruction decoding. And you should be able to accelerate it on a GPU or TPU.
  • If you use the lower-case instructions with asm() and exe(), then execution of these functions is slow as they involve look-up and string matching with O(n) complexity where "n" is the total number of instructions. The current implementations of asm() and dec() are optimized for ease-of-use and readability. A faster implementation would collapse multiple look-ups into one look-up, optimize the pattern-matching for the instruction decoding (bits -> instruction), and change the order of the instructions so that more frequently used instructions are at the top of the list. Here is an older version of TinyFive with a faster dec() function that collapses two look-ups (bits -> instruction and instruction -> uppeer-case instruction) and doesn't use fnmatch.

Comparison

The table below compares TinyFive with other ISS and emulator projects.

ISS Author Language Mature? Extensions LOC
TinyFive OpenMachine Python No I, M, some F < 1k
Pydgin Cornell University Python, C Last update 2016 A, D, F, I, M
Spike UC Berkeley C, C++ Yes All
QEMU Fabrice Bellard C Yes All
TinyEMU Fabrice Bellard C Yes All
riscvOVPsim Imperas C Yes All
Whisper Western Digital C, C++ Yes Almost all
Sail Model Cambridge, Edinburgh Sail, C Yes All
PiMaker/rvc PiMaker C
mini-rv32ima Charles Lohr C A, I, M, Zifencei, Zicsr < 1k

References

Tiny Tech promise

Similar to TinyEMU, tinygrad, and other “tiny tech” projects, we believe that core technology should be simple and small (in terms of LOC). Therefore, we will make sure that the core of TinyFive (without tests and examples) will always be below 1000 lines.

Simplicity and size (in terms of number of instructions) is a key feature of RISC: the "R" in RISC stands for "reduced" (as opposed to complex CISC). Specifically, the ISA manual of RISC-V has only ~200 pages while the ARM-32 manual is over 2000 pages long according to Fig. 1.6 of the RISC-V Reader.