Replace Android Asynctask with Kotlin Coroutines (or RxJava)

If you're like me, you use the AsyncTask class a lot, because, you know, it was recommended by Google for a decade. And if you're like me, you panicked in horror when you learned it was deprecated by Google in Android 11 (SDK 30).

See this video.

So there are some choices if you've used it a lot.

1. Quickly learn Kotlin and rewrite everything you've ever done to use coroutines or refactor everything to use java.util.concurrent.
2. Ignore the deprecation and assume Android will always support AsyncTask even though they say not to use it.
3. Really cheat and add the source code of AsyncTask directly in my project, call it MySyncTask, and pretend none of this ever happened.

But maybe a drop-in replacement might work? I looked on github and found a Kotlin class CoroutinesAsyncTask.kt written originally by ladrahul25 (which was further modified by me, fat-tire) with a Kotlin-based activity that could help migrate an AsyncTask to Kotlin coroutine.

Not every method from AsyncTask is supported here, but with some tweaking of the original code and stuff, onPreExecute, doInBackground(), onProgressUpdate(), publishProgress(), and onPostExecute(), and maybe even OnCanceled() kinda work. That last one is kind of a work-in-progress.

Since I'd never used RxJava before either and barely understand it, I decided to create a similar RxJava-type AsyncTask replacement class to compare. The result is a class named RxASyncTask.java.

The demo app here includes BOTH replacement classes used in (1) A Java Activity as well as (2) A Kotlin Activity.

You can try them both and see if either of them work. And please send any pull requests because I truly have no idea what I'm doing, not having used RxJava or Kotlin before this.

I seriously can't promise anything here. But it may be a start for someone to play with who knows more about this stuff or like me wants to learn.

CoroutinesAsyncTask Notes

This is probaby the one you want to try first. If you've got a Java project going and want to try it, you'll need to enable Kotlin first because, well, this was written in Kotlin -- coroutines aren't available in Java. But you can use it from Java. Look at the demo activities (.kt and .java) to get an idea of how it might work.

To Use the CoroutinesAsyncTask class

• First enable Kotlin in your project. This is a couple lines to build.gradle and instructions are available elsewhere for this.

• Now add CoroutineAsyncTask.kt to your project's source code and replace the package line with your package.

• Change any line in your original code that references AsyncTask to extend CoroutineAsyncTask instead.

Be sure to check out the demo activities to see this in action.

RxASyncTask Notes

Thanks to this link by Pierce Zaifman suggesting what to put where, I thought I could maybe also try to make an AsyncTask-compatible class with RxJava.

This experiment seems to work-- with some minor caveats...

To Use the RxASyncTask class

• First, add RxASyncTask.java to your project's source code and replace the package line with your package.

• If you're doing more i/o work than computation work, change Schedulers.io() to Schedulers.computation(). Not really sure what the difference is, but I think it's whether or not it creates more threads than CPU cores or not (io = yes, computation = no).

• Add these lines to build.gradle to bring in the rxJava/rxAndroid dependencies. (The version number may be different.)

    implementation 'io.reactivex.rxjava3:rxandroid:3.0.0'
    implementation 'io.reactivex.rxjava3:rxjava:3.0.4'
  

• You may need to add some lines to proguard-rules.pro if you use R8 and run into issues.

• Change any line in your original code that extends AsyncTask to extend RxASyncTask instead.

• RxASyncTask's doInBackground() can't return type Void (which must always be null) because in the RxJava world, the result passed to onNext() is always set to @NonNull. If you don't know what that means, don't worry about it. I barely do either. But there's an easy fix:

SOLUTION: Just change any Void to Boolean and return false instead of null. For example:

private static class MyAddTask extends RxSyncTask<Void, Void, Void> {

would need to become:

private static class MyAddTask extends RxSyncTask<Void, Void, Boolean> {

and

protected Void doInBackground(Void... Void)  {

becomes

protected Boolean doInBackground(Void... Void) {

and then, in doInBackground() any time you:

 return null;

Now you

 return false;

And finally

protected void onPostExecute(Void result) {

becomes

protected void onPostExecute(Boolean result) {

As with CoroutineAsyncTask, look at the demo activities (kt and java) to see it sort of in action.

I probably should have named the class RxAsyncTask with a lower-case "s" to match AsyncTask... but it's RxASyncTask. Oh well.

--fat-tire