i18n "ERROR in Unknown placeholder INTERPOLATION_1" with specific values

[n00b42]

Bug Report or Feature Request (mark with an x)

- [x] bug report -> please search issues before submitting
- [ ] feature request

Versions.

@angular/cli: 1.3.2
node: 8.2.1
os: linux x64
@angular/animations: 4.3.6
@angular/common: 4.3.6
@angular/compiler: 4.3.6
@angular/core: 4.3.6
@angular/forms: 4.3.6
@angular/http: 4.3.6
@angular/platform-browser: 4.3.6
@angular/platform-browser-dynamic: 4.3.6
@angular/router: 4.3.6
@angular/cli: 1.3.2
@angular/compiler-cli: 4.3.6
@angular/language-service: 4.3.6

Repro steps.

ng new test-i18n

app.component.html - Add the following line:

<div i18n>Page {{'5'}} of {{'5'}}</div>

Extract Translation Data

ng xi18n --locale en --output-path src/i18n

"Translate" the file using some tool, in this case just copying the source to target, saving as "messages.en.xlf"

ng serve --aot --i18n-file=src/i18n/messages.en.xlf --i18n-format=xlf --locale=en

The log given by the failure.

ERROR in Unknown placeholder "INTERPOLATION_1" ("Page of [ERROR ->]"): i18n@0:32

Desired functionality.

Shows "Page 5 of 5" instead of error.

Mention any other details that might be useful.

The error only occured if BOTH Interpolation parts were '5'

Using anything else: e.g. variables (page_offset), other numbers ('4' with '5' or '1' with '1'), numbers instead of strings (5), even using double quotes ("5") DID NOT result in the error.

This means after knowing that I can easily get around that, but still it is a very confusing issue.....

Or is there something I did not see?

[ocombe]

Hello, can you give me the content of your xlf file please ?
Is this reproducible in plunkr?

[n00b42]

messages.en.xlf.zip

(Do not know about Plunkr, never had Angular running there, especially with i18n)

[ocombe]

So based on your xlf file:

<source>Page <x id="INTERPOLATION"/> of <x id="INTERPOLATION"/></source>
<target state="translated">Page <x id="INTERPOLATION"/> of <x id="INTERPOLATION_1"/></target>

In source you have two times INTERPOLATION but in target you have: INTERPOLATION and INTERPOLATION_1 which is why it doesn't work (INTERPOLATION_1 doesn't exist)

[n00b42]

Hm, so the tool is to blame that I used to make the translation, will have a look at that.

But still wondering why Angular i18n reacts so strange in that case...

[ocombe]

well the IDs are used to match your translations with the content of your templates, if the ID is wrong then it fails and throws

[pmccloghrylaing]

For anyone encountering this error and ending up here - this can also occur if you've given identical IDs to two different messages.

[Alaeddine22]

@ocombe
Hello i'm currently working with i18n also and i found problems with translating dynamic text
How does i18n solve it ?

[ocombe]

We plan to add a service for dynamic translations at runtime in ivy (the new renderer that we are working on). Right now it's not possible with built-in i18n.

[angular-automatic-lock-bot]

This issue has been automatically locked due to inactivity.
Please file a new issue if you are encountering a similar or related problem.

Read more about our automatic conversation locking policy.

_{This action has been performed automatically by a bot.}