馃懟 Cemeteries #329
馃懟 Cemeteries #329
Conversation
|
The tombstone icon is very strong. I don鈥檛 see many icons like that in the current deployment. In Openstreetmap Carto there is a repeating pattern across the area, and it changes it based on the religion of the cemetery, rather than showing an icon next to the name. A similar idea is also used in Opencyclemap and CyclOSM. Most cemeteries are mapped as areas so an icon is not needed by the name if the area rendering is understandable. I would recommend using a different color, not the same as parks. |
|
Below are the cemetery treatments I found in my map collection, previously posted in the Slack thread linked above. In the future, let鈥檚 open a separate issue for features we want to render so we can more easily discuss the possibilities independently of a particular implementation.
Depending on the publisher, I鈥檝e seen a green fill matching parks or something more drab; a repeating religious symbol pattern, or a solid fill juxtaposed with a tree cover鈥搇ike pattern for parks. The icon is probably only necessary at low and mid zoom levels where the label has the potential to overflow outside the bounds of the cemetery, making the location less obvious. In most maps that symbolize cemeteries with icons at smaller scales, the icon is a religious symbol matching the symbol for a place of worship, or it鈥檚 just a square or dot matching any other POI. Arlington National Cemetery demonstrates the need for the vector tiles to represent cemetery sectors differently than cemeteries. Currently, they鈥檙e tagged as nested |
At the moment, we don't have any POIs rendered, so the map is effectively blank of icons, with the exception of places and highway shields. I'm working behind the scenes to set up the infrastructure for POI icons with recolorable SDFs in an efficient way but that's a bit off. So I wouldn't consider the lack of other icons to be a stylistic choice but rather an indicator of incompletion.
Religion tagging is not available in OpenMapTiles. This is not a deal-breaker if we decide we want to render it, but if we do, we would either have to get it added to OpenMapTiles or else render a custom layer (for example using the new customizability feature implemented in onthegomap/planetiler#160) and get it hosted somewhere. If we do want religion-specific tagging rendered, we'll probably want something generic to render as a temporary measure until the tagging can get added to the tiles. |
In that case, a solid color without a pattern would be fine. |
|
Blocked by #387 |
|
The infrastructure is now in place for POIs, however, no icons in the "green" class have been implemented yet. |
|
Updated imagery showing potential differentiated park/cemetery rendering:
I'm finding that if I darken the colors too much, it clashes with cased roads. |
|
PR Preview: Sprite Sheets:
|
Fix typo
This is an initial implementation of cemetery rendering. Starting this as draft so folks can play with it as we don't have an agreement on the styling yet. This implementation uses the same fill and stroke as parks, and adds a grave POI icon. However, based on the initial slack discussion, there is a preference towards rendering cemeteries in a color distinct from parks.
Location: https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/8551292
