Nitrokey HOTP Verification Tool

Nitrokey HOTP Verification Tool is a command line application, which communicates with a HOTP USB Security Dongle (over HIDAPI/libusb or CCID) to configure HOTP secrets and to verify HOTP codes. The Dongle being used needs to support HOTP verification, which is - at the time of writing - supported by Nitrokey Pro, Nitrokey Storage, Nitrokey 3 and Librem Key.

This solution is meant to allow one to verify the authenticity of his computer. During the boot process, the user will be asked to insert his HOTP USB Security Dongle device, which would then compare the on-device generated HOTP code and the one sent by the computer under verification. Afterward the Nitrokey indicates the verification result by LED animation:

• OTP codes are equal - success => green LED blinking;
• OTP codes are different - failure => red LED blinking quicker.

Requirements

This tool uses HIDAPI library to communicate with the Nitrokey device. It is a light wrapper over the libusb API and requires usb-1.0 library at the link time.

For HID use this tool also reads from /dev/urandom to generate a session secret for the device-authorization purposes used in libnitrokey.

The USB HOTP Security Dongle device needs to support HOTP verification.

The CCID interface is implemented to support Nitrokey 3, which uses Secrets App for its OTP handling.

Compilation

CMake

This tool uses CMake for compilation as its main driver. Please run:

mkdir build && cd build
cmake .. && make

To list compilation options please use:

$ cmake -LH ..
-- Configuring done
-- Generating done
-- Build files have been written to: /home/sz/work/nitrokey-hotp-verification/build-clang
-- Cache values
// Add information about source code version from Git repository
ADD_GIT_INFO:BOOL=ON

// Print debug information to stdout
ADD_LOG:BOOL=OFF

// Choose the type of build, options are: None(CMAKE_CXX_FLAGS or CMAKE_C_FLAGS used) Debug Release RelWithDebInfo MinSizeRel.
CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE:STRING=Debug

// Install path prefix, prepended onto install directories.
CMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX:PATH=/usr/local

// Link application against system HIDAPI library
USE_SYSTEM_HIDAPI:BOOL=OFF

Example compilation flags use:

cmake .. -DADD_GIT_INFO=OFF -DCMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Release

Makefile

To support reproducible build within Heads, additional build method using Gnu Make was added. To run:

make

• At the moment hidapi library will always be bundled statically.
• It is possible to provide libusb flags with LIBUSB_FLAGS and LIBUSB_LIB, otherwise it will be taken from the pkg-config.
• Cross-compilation can be achieved overwriting standard build variables.
• To disable embedding Git version it suffices to set GITVERSION to none.
• Additional helper command was added to quickly compute SHA256 sum for Heads inclusion, and could be executed with make github_sha.

Meson

Meson was added as a backup method in case, when build reproducibility could not be achieved with Gnu Makefile. It is not configurable. Usage:

meson builddir
cd builddir && ninja

Usage

Before each device-related command a connection attempt will be done. If the Nitrokey Pro will not be detected immediately, the tool will monit for its insertion and will wait for 40 seconds (probing each 0.5s), quitting if connection would not be possible.

Parameters in triangular braces <> are required, while these in square ones [] are optional.

Setting HOTP secret

To set a new HOTP secret to be verified on the device please run:

./nitrokey_hotp_verification set <BASE32 HOTP SECRET> <ADMIN PIN> [COUNTER]

where:

• BASE32 HOTP SECRET is a new base32 HOTP secret, with up to 160 bits of length;
• ADMIN PIN is a current Admin PIN of the device. Nitrokey 3 allows to skip providing it by accepting empty string as an argument: "";
• COUNTER is an optional argument holding an initial value for the HOTP counter to be set on the device.

Verifying HOTP code

To verify the HOTP code please run check command as in:

./nitrokey_hotp_verification check <HOTP CODE>

where: HOTP CODE is a 6-digits HOTP code to verify

In case where the code is verified on the device, the green LED will blink 5 times. Otherwise, the red LED will blink 5 times, twice as fast as the green.

Verification of 8-digits codes is available as an option through build configuration in settings.h. Responsible flag is configured on device during the HOTP secret setup phase and cannot be changed (until another secret rewrite) in the current implementation.

Solution contains means to avoid desynchronization between the host's and device's counters. Device calculates up to 9 values ahead of its current counter to find the matching code (in total it calculates HOTP code for 10 subsequent counter positions). In case:

• no code would match - the on-device counter will not be changed;
• code would match, but with some counter's offset (up to 9) - the on-device counter will be set to matched code-generated HOTP counter and incremented by 1;
• code would match, and the code matches counter without offset - the counter will be incremented by 1.

Device will stop verifying the HOTP codes in case, when the difference between the host and on-device counters will be greater or equal to 10.

This allows to boot the system without USB Security Dongle 9 times, until it would lose synchronization and would need to be set up again.

Identifying the device

To show information about the connected device please use:

$ ./nitrokey_hotp_verification info
# which results should be similar to:
HOTP code verification application, version 1.4
Connected device status:
 Card serial: 0x5F11
 Firmware: v0.9
 Card counters: Admin 3, User 3

To show only the card's serial please run:

$ ./nitrokey_hotp_verification id

AES key regeneration

Tool supports AES key regeneration call, which should be called after each GnuPG factory-reset operation for Nitrokey Pro, Librem Key and Nitrokey Storage devices. Example call:

./nitrokey_hotp_verification regenerate 12345678

Complete example

# set 160-bit secret with RFC's test secret "12345678901234567890"
./nitrokey_hotp_verification set GEZDGNBVGY3TQOJQGEZDGNBVGY3TQOJQ 12345678
./nitrokey_hotp_verification check 755224
./nitrokey_hotp_verification check 287082
./nitrokey_hotp_verification check 359152

# show response to a wrong code
./nitrokey_hotp_verification check 111111

Help screen

HOTP code verification application, version 1.4
Available commands:
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification id
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification info
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification version
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification check <HOTP CODE>
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification regenerate <ADMIN PIN>
 ./nitrokey_hotp_verification set <BASE32 HOTP SECRET> <ADMIN PIN> [COUNTER]

Exit codes

In case the tool would encounter any critical issues, it will print error message and return to the OS with a proper exit code value. Meaning of the exit values could be checked with the following table:

Error code name	Exit code	Meaning
EXIT_NO_ERROR	0	Operation was completed successfully or HOTP code was confirmed to be valid
EXIT_CONNECTION_ERROR	1	Could not connect to the Nitrokey Pro device
EXIT_WRONG_PIN	2	Could not authorize the user with the user given PIN
EXIT_OTHER_ERROR	3	Unknown error
EXIT_INVALID_HOTP_CODE	4	Entered HOTP code was calculated to be invalid
EXIT_UNKNOWN_COMMAND	5	Device does not support HOTP verification command in this firmware
EXIT_SLOT_NOT_PROGRAMMED	6	On-device slot was not programmed with HOTP secret yet
EXIT_BAD_FORMAT	7	Either entered HOTP code for validation or base32 secret to set was in improper format (too long or consisting of invalid characters)
EXIT_CONNECTION_LOST	8	Connection to the device was lost during the process
EXIT_INVALID_PARAMS	100	Application could not parse command line arguments

Tests

Solution was tested against 160-bits test vectors available at RFC_HOTP-test-vectors.txt.

Environment

• Ubuntu 18.04
• gcc (Ubuntu 7.3.0-16ubuntu3) 7.3.0
• libusb-1.0 package version: 2:1.0.21-2
• CMake 3.10.2

Code analysers:

• Valgrind-3.13.0
• Cppcheck 1.82
• Clang tools package version: 1:5.0.1-4

Code correctness

Code was tested against Valgrind, Clang static checker (scan-build) and Cppcheck. Compilation is run with all warnings enabled (flags -Wall -Wextra).

Unit tests

With -DCOMPILE_TESTS=TRUE compilation switch it is possible to compile tests, which are checking the solution against RFC specification. Details are available at tests/test_hotp.cpp. To run them please issue:

./test_hotp

Tests could be run selectively - see --help switch to learn more.

Warning: before running the tests please make sure to use a not production device to avoid important data removal. Tests use default Admin PIN: 12345678.

Size

In a Release build, with statically linked HIDAPI, application takes 50kB of storage (42kB stripped).

Build reproducibility

Build reproducibility was tested with Repro-test tool. Docker files for Ubuntu and Fedora are provided for tests on both systems. See https://reproducible-builds.org/ for more details. Following commands will build Docker environments, execute tool builds and show final SHA256 hashes of the binaries:

make -f Makefile-repro.mk repro-build
make -f Makefile-repro.mk repro-run

Development

When NDEBUG is set, the log messages are not printed out.

License

Code is licensed under GPLv3, excluding base32.{h,c} files. The latter are downloaded from tpmtopt project and seem to be licensed under MIT license.