[1.14.4] Server list says "Server mod list is not compatible" if the server is missing clientside-only mods

[aaronhowser1]

Minecraft Version: 1.14.4

Forge Version: forge-28.1.93

Logs: {Link(s) to GitHub Gist with full latest.log and/or crash report}

Steps to Reproduce:

1. Make a modpack that has clientside mods
2. Make a server using it, remove the clientside mods from it
3. Add that server to the server list of a client that has the clientside mods

Description of issue:

[JoJoDeveloping]

Well, it shouldn't. Can you tell us which modpack you are using? It's quite likely that there actually is a mod that doesn't correctly implement the compatibility check functions, leading forge to assume it's not compatible.

Alternatively, post a debug.log, because that contains further information about what mods cause rejection and why..

[aaronhowser1]

The modpack is unreleased, but here's the modlist:

I'll be able to post the debug.log later

[aaronhowser1]

Here is the debug.log

[JoJoDeveloping]

Your log seems to be the server log yet the information about why the client is misprocessing the data is found in the client debug.log

[aaronhowser1]

Oh right, sorry. Here's my client's
debug.log from launching the game, opening the multiplayer menu (but not joining), and then going to resource packs to more quickly get the file.

[JoJoDeveloping]

Thank you. There are several problems I see here - one is that dcintegration apparently sends itself across the network which it shouldn't..
Apart from that some other client mods also apparently have DISPLAYTEST extensionpoint registered which indicates failure although I can't see which from the debug log. I'll test this some more. It'ld be helpful if you could release the mods list in a more usable format.

[aaronhowser1]

Here's all the file names

• AmbientSounds_v3.0.14_mc1.14.4.jar
• AppleSkin-mc1.14.4-forge-1.0.12.jar
• bambooeverything-1.14-1.4.0.jar
• BetterCaves-1.14.4-1.0.1.jar
• BetterThanBunnies-1.14.4-1.2.0.jar
• BetterThanLlamas-1.14.4-1.1.0.jar
• ChunkNoGoByeBye-1.14.4-1.0.3.jar
• Clumps-4.0.0.jar
• CobbleForDays-1.0.2.jar
• cofh_core-1.14.4-0.1.1b.jar
• comforts-FORGE-1.14.4-2.0-beta4.jar
• Controlling-5.0.4.jar
• CraftingTweaks_1.14.4-10.1.4.jar
• create-mc1.14.4_v0.1.1a.jar
• CyclopsCore-1.14.4-1.6.0.jar
• Ding-1.14.4-1.1.0.jar
• earthmobsmod-1.14.4-0.1.0.4-Beta.jar
• embellishcraft-1.14.4-1.3.1.jar
• ensorcellation-1.14.4-0.1.1b.jar
• EverlastingAbilities-1.14.4-1.6.0.jar
• FastFurnace-1.14.4-2.2.4.jar
• FastLeafDecay-v17.jar
• FastWorkbench-1.14.4-2.1.4.jar
• findme-1.14.4-1.1.0.13.jar
• FTBUtilitiesBackups-2.0.0.11.jar
• furniture-7.0.0-pre12-1.14.4.jar
• Harvest-forge-1.14.4-1.2.10-23.jar
• healingcf_1.14-1.7.jar
• inventorysorter-1.14.4-16.2.0.jar
• jei-1.14.4-6.0.0.25.jar
• JustEnoughResources-1.14.4-0.10.0.66.jar
• MCFurnace-1.14.4-DEV-1.3.2.jar
• modnametooltip_1.14.3-1.12.1.jar
• moreoverlays-1.16.1.jar
• Morpheus-1.14.4-4.2.43.jar
• mysticallib-1.14.4-1.8.0.jar
• mysticalwildlife-1.14.4-1.3.3.jar
• mysticalworld-1.14.4-1.6.10.jar
• nhacampfire_1.14-1.5.jar
• nifty-1.14.4-2.7.1.jar
• Placebo-1.14.4-2.3.5.jar
• quartz-chests-1.0.0.1.jar
• seals-1.14.4-1.0.2.jar
• ShadesOfNether-0.1.jar
• SimpleDiscordRichPresence-1.0.2.jar
• SimpleStorageNetwork-1.14.4-0.1.0.jar
• simplylight-0.9.0.jar
• speedyhoppers-1.14.4-7.jar
• StevesFactoryManager-1.14.4-3.0.0-alpha19.jar
• StoneChest-1.14.4-1.0.1.jar
• StorageDrawers-1.14.4-6.0.5.jar
• theoneprobe-1.14-1.4.37.jar
• tombstone-4.1.7-1.14.4.jar
• TOOLKIT-1.2.0.jar
• watercan-1.14.4-2.1.0.jar
• wildnature-2.0.5.jar

[JoJoDeveloping]

Yeah, so downloading these mods manually (which took about an hour), and looking at the data coming from your server shows that there are three mods not playing nice:

• AmbientSounds
• MoreOverlays
• DiscordIntegration

MoreOverlays can be run on the server, where it won't do anything (also not taking up any resources). AmbientSounds says it's client side only via mods.toml, but that is actually not something you can specify in there. So you should be able to also run it on the server, where it will not take up any ressources, not do anything but stop the client mod from being confused about it's server side missing.
DiscordIntegration is the tricky one - IDK how it handles being installed on the client.

But apart from that these mods should be aware of the fact that they're supposed to be client side only. However they're naughty and do not override the DISPLAYTEST extensionpoint, where they would have the option of not interfering with the client compatibility checking. So if you want this fixed and the mods can't simply be put onto the server, go yell at their authors.

[stale]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had activity in a long time. If this issue is still relevant and should remain open, please reply with a short explanation (e.g. "I have checked the code and this issue is still relevant because ___." or "Here's a screenshot of this issue on the latest version"). Thank you for your contributions!

[stale]

This issue has been automatically closed because it has not had activity in a long time. Please feel free to reopen it or create a new issue.

[aaronhowser1]

bad bot