Skip to content

DesiQuintans/Pebble-safe

Repository files navigation

Pebble-Safe, a colourblind-safe RStudio theme

(Hey, kid, if you're looking for a better light theme that's colourblind-safe, try my new theme called Epergoes. Okay bye!)

Preview

Pebble-Safe is a colourblind-friendly theme for RStudio. It comes in Light and Dark variants, but I recommend the Dark variant because it makes better use of the few safe colours that are available. The font used in the screenshots below is Hack in 10 pt https://sourcefoundry.org/hack.

Installation

You need to be running RStudio v 1.2.x or greater.

First, install the rstudioapi package.

install.packages("rstudioapi")

Then, run the commands below to install the theme.

# Dark variant
rstudioapi::addTheme("https://github.com/DesiQuintans/Pebble-safe/releases/download/1.0.0/Pebble-Safe_Dark.rstheme",
apply = TRUE, force = TRUE)

# Light variant:
rstudioapi::addTheme("https://github.com/DesiQuintans/Pebble-safe/releases/download/1.0.0/Pebble-Safe_Light.rstheme",
apply = TRUE, force = TRUE)

You can change the active theme at any time by going to (Tools → Global Options → Appearance) and applying a new theme.

The themes can be uninstalled by selecting them in the list and clicking (Remove).


Nerd info about how I chose a colourblind-friendly palette

Choosing colours for syntax highlighting has a few extra difficulties compared to designing a poster or chart:

  1. Text at normal sizes has thinner outlines that make subtle colours harder to differentiate.
  2. Syntax highlighting is supposed to convey more information to the reader, and it’s hard to convey lots of information with a smaller palette of styles and still have each type of information clearly distinct from the others.
  3. The background of the text can affect the clarity of the colours. Yellow is one of the few safe colours out there, and yellow text on a white background is basically unreadable.

I found a few reliable sources for colourblind-friendly colour palettes.

This table of 8 colours is from Wong (2011).

Wong, Bang. “Points of View: Color Blindness.” Nature Methods 8 (May 27, 2011): 441.
https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth.1618.

This table of qualitative colors is from the RColorBrewer package.

Erich Neuwirth (2014). RColorBrewer: ColorBrewer Palettes. R package version 1.1-2.
https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=RColorBrewer

display.brewer.all(type = "qual", colorblindFriendly = TRUE)

And this table of colours is from Sasha Trubetskoy.

Trubetskoy, Sasha. List of 20 Simple, Distinct Colors. https://sashat.me/2017/01/11/list-of-20-simple-distinct-colors, accessed 2019-02-27.

sasha_cols <- c("#FFE119", "#4363D8", "#F58231", "#FABEBE", "#E6BEFF", 
                "#800000", "#000075", "#A9A9A9", "#FFFFFF", "#000000")

show_colours(sasha_cols)

Testing the colours

Here are all of the colours in one swatch. I’ve also added #FCFCFC, my preferred light background colour, just a whisker off pure white so it’s a little easier on the eyes.

raw_cols <- c("#666666", "#A6761D", "#E6AB02", "#66A61E", "#E7298A", "#7570B3", 
              "#D95F02", "#1B9E77", "#A6CEE3", "#1F78B4", "#B2DF8A", "#33A02C", 
              "#FB9A99", "#E31A1C", "#FDBF6F", "#FF7F00", "#CAB2D6", "#6A3D9A", 
              "#FFFF99", "#B15928", "#B3B3B3", "#E5C494", "#FFD92F", "#A6D854", 
              "#E78AC3", "#8DA0CB", "#FC8D62", "#66C2A5", "#CD7EAA", "#D5683A", 
              "#2A78B5", "#F1E54E", "#2AA179", "#62B6E6", "#E7A337", "#292929",
              "#FFE119", "#4363D8", "#F58231", "#FABEBE", "#E6BEFF", "#800000", 
              "#000075", "#FCFCFC", "#A9A9A9")

show_colours(raw_cols)

Try to programmatically remove similar colours under red-green blindness

This is what the colour tiles above look like when deuteranopia (the most common kind of colourblindness) is simulated with Color Oracle https://colororacle.org/.

deut_cols <- c("#666666", "#868614", "#BEBE00", "#969626", "#888886", "#7171B2", 
               "#909000", "#888879", "#C3C3E3", "#6767B5", "#D2D28B", "#8A8A34", 
               "#BDBD95", "#838300", "#D3D36C", "#B0B000", "#B9B9D5", "#4E4E99", 
               "#FEFE99", "#7B7B21", "#B2B2B2", "#CECE93", "#E4E42A", "#CACA57", 
               "#ABABC0", "#9A9ACB", "#B6B65D", "#ADADA6", "#9A9AA8", "#939331", 
               "#6868B5", "#E8E84E", "#8A8A7B", "#A2A2E6", "#B9B931", "#2A2A2A", 
               "#E9E914", "#5B5BD8", "#ADAD21", "#D1D1BC", "#CACAFE", "#4A4A00", 
               "#141475", "#FBFBFB", "#A8A8A8")

show_colours(deut_cols)

I can take these deuteranopia colours, convert them to RGB space, round their RGB scores to a common scale (e.g. round them to the nearest 10), and programmatically eliminate colours that are at the same RGB point.

round_rgb <- function(hexcol, to = 1, dir = NULL) {
    col2rgb(hexcol) %>% 
        round_to_nearest(to = to, dir = dir) %>% 
        paste(collapse = " ")
}

cols <- 
    tibble(hex_col = raw_cols,
           hex_deut = deut_cols) %>% 
    rowwise() %>% 
    mutate_at(vars(starts_with("hex_")), 
              list(round = ~ round_rgb(., 10))) %>% 
    distinct(hex_deut_round, .keep_all = TRUE) %>% 
    distinct(hex_col_round, .keep_all = TRUE)

show_colours(cols$hex_col)

We eliminated these 3 colours :

show_colours(c("#2A78B5", "#2AA179", "#A9A9A9"), main = "Excluded colours")

Manually select colours under red-green blindness

show_colours(cols$hex_deut)

I hand-picked all of the colours that I could easily differentiate, trying to maximise the differences between them. I made sure they were easy to differentiate them by dragging them beside each other in my colour picker (JCPicker http://annystudio.com/software/colorpicker) and squinting at their differences.

Selected theme colours

So I guess these are my theme colours! These colours are okay under simulated deuteranopia, protanopia, and tritanopia.

## Normal vision colours:

## [1] "#292929" "#4363D8" "#E7298A" "#E6BEFF" "#FFE119" "#FCFCFC" "#FFFF99"

## 
## Deuteranopic version:

## [1] "#E9E914" "#FEFE99" "#CACAFE" "#5B5BD8" "#2A2A2A" "#888886" "#FBFBFB"

Designing the themes

(These are notes for the author and for any other theme authors who want to know the process. If you are a user, you only need to follow the Installation instructions above.)

It is often easier to visualise design changes by editing the stylesheet live in the inspector. Right-click on the RStudio editor pane and choose Inspect Element. In the left nav pane of the inspector, choose theme/custom/local → your .rsTheme file. You can edit the settings here but you cannot save the changes in the inspector.

1. Use a GUI editor to make a .tmTheme

I use https://tmtheme-editor.herokuapp.com. The RStudio theme backend has only some limited scopes, and the colourblind-friendly palette is so limited that I can’t use all of them anyway.

These are the resources for designing a theme:

Scope names that are actually used in RStudio

I compiled this list by editing the 3024 Day theme in TmTheme Editor, changing all of the colours to a unique colour in a series (#DDDD01, #DDDD02, …). I downloaded the .tmTheme, converted it to .rsTheme with rstudioapi::convertTheme(), and then retrieved all of the colour codes that were still present in the converted document.

Once that was done I extracted all of the scope names for the preserved colours, put them into a new theme, and assigned each name a unique colour from desiderata::palette_distinct(spaced = FALSE). I downloaded the theme, converted it, and then viewed one of my Rmarkdown files in high zoom while using a colour picker tool to find out which of the unique colours were actually used by RStudio.

tmTheme Editor tab Scope GUI effect Code syntax highlighting Rmarkdown highlighting
General background Pane background colour.
General caret Text cursor colour.
General foreground All plain/unstyled text. Argument names.
General invisibles Invisible objects such as non-breaking spaces.
General lineHighlight Current-line marker.
General selection Selection box (when drag-selecting text).
Scopes comment Comments in code. Text in Roxygen blocks.
Scopes constant.language Messages, errors, and warnings. TRUE, FALSE, NA, NULL, NaN, Inf, etc. Italicised text (*text* or _text_).
Scopes constant.numeric Numbers. Bold text (**text**).
Scopes keyword Function names. Roxygen fields (e.g. @param).
Scopes keyword.operator Brackets, assignment arrows, operators.
Scopes markup.heading Headings, only the # characters. The rest of the heading text must be edited in the .rsTheme CSS.
Scopes meta.tag Metadata tags in YAML header (title, output, …)
Scopes string Character strings. Block quotes (> text). Strings in YAML header.
Scopes support.class Package namespace names (dplyr::)
Scopes support.function Function names if “Highlight R function calls” is enabled. Argument names in Roxygen block. Preformatted text (`text`). Code block headers. Special characters in YAML header.

2. Convert it to a .rsTheme in RStudio

rstudioapi::convertTheme("src/Pebble-safe Light.tmTheme")
rstudioapi::convertTheme("src/Pebble-safe Dark.tmTheme")

3. Edit the theme CSS by hand

Not much functionality is exposed via the editor theme scopes. These features need to be added by hand.

These edits are made inside the converted .rstheme files. For me, these files are located in Documents\.R\rstudio\themes. I edit them in place and copy them to this repo to distribute them.

Fix heading style

Only the text colour of the markdown headings can be safely changed. Changing the background colour masks the selection box, and changing the text size makes the cursor no longer line-up with the text on that header line.

.ace_markup.ace_heading {
  text-decoration: underline;
  color: #REPLACEME;
}

.ace_heading {
  text-decoration: underline;
  color: #REPLACEME;

}

Matching bracket indicator

Make it magenta to match the cursor.

.ace_bracket {
  margin: 0 !important;
  border: 0 !important;
  background-color: #CURSORCOLOUR;
}

Markdown block background

I made the background of the markdown blocks more similar to the normal background, and I added borders on the left and right sides of the block to delineate it.

I ideally would have liked to have a line at the top and bottom of the block, but the style is applied on a per-line basis and the block itself is not a single box element.

.ace_marker-layer .ace_foreign_line {
  position: absolute;
  z-index: -1;
  background-color: #fdfdfd; for light
  background-color: #2d2d2d; for dark
  border-right: 2px solid #cccccc;
  margin-right: 5px;
}

Column margin line

The default is too bright in the Dark variant.

.ace_print-margin {
  width: 1px;
  background: #424242;
}