Gestures for Magic Mouse on Mac client #2905
Comments
If gamepad support is being worked on I think more emphasis should be put on multi touch gestures as they are becoming more and more ubiquitous. |
To be clear, trackpad gestures are completely non-functional even on the server itself while Synergy is running. Synergy must be exited before gestures will work. This pretty much makes a Mac desktop with a trackpad unusable at this time. |
Gestures on the server with synergys running work in 1.3.8, but it appears that that got lost in 1.4. |
Just confirming the feature does not exist in 1.4.7 on OSX Lion. I am running 1.4.7 as the server on my Mac OSX Lion side and 1.4.7 as the client on my Ubuntu 11.10 side. Everything is great except no trackpad gestures are working mac-side. Much appreciated on the hard work and great software! |
Revision 1175 introduced this problem. Reverting that commit from the source allows multi-touch gestures to work again on my MacBook Pro 17's trackpad. An alternate fix would be to limit the allowed types to be NX_LASTEVENT + 2, as the three-finger swipes I am most familiar with (left and right swipe) are the next two values above NX_LASTEVENT. |
I've grabbed the latest Nitely 1.4.9 1390 issue remains. |
Something I would like to add is that with this once the :NOTE: Ignoring Out of Bounds Quartz Event type: 0x1d [max 0x1c] shows in the log up and down scrolling with the magic mouse is broken as well. |
Can't find a nightly that built properly for 10.7 in order to test this fix. Builds are broken for all platforms except windows |
Just tried with rev 1432 for mac 10.7, still not working. I'm seeing Has this been patched? I thought it was. I see in the log: |
Alex B wrote:
same here :( |
New bug manager.. and now the patch is missing. I have time to attempt apply it and get this guy working................. |
Marty, try now. |
Got it.. I'll be applying the patch and see what I get tomorrow.. |
I can conferm that with the patch applied I get magic mouse and trackpad scroll and gestures. [Server] Macbook pro 5,1 OSX 10.7.4 Synergy (head of 1.4 branch) svn Patch applied [Clinet] OptiPlex 790 Ubuntu 12.04 Synergy Nightly 1.4.9 deb package. |
Cheers Marty, the patch will be in the next release. |
installed synergy on my MacBook (server) and Win7 PC (Client), was really excited about how seamlessly it was working until I discovered this bug. Trackpad and Magic Mouse are both out of business, is that patch available somewhere I can easily grab it, or when is the next release expected? Thanks! |
Does one of the daily builds have the patch? (tried the latest available as of 6/19 for mac but it still quits scrolling after a bit) Love synergy, and it's still easier to start and stop it when i need to access the peecee, but i'd rather not :) |
Hey, Thanks! |
The patch won't add any gesture support (I mean, the ability to send gestures to other machines). It will just avoid breaking gestures in the server machine when synergy is running (and cause issues like bug #3195). |
Where do we get this patch and how is it applied? Would love to have gestures working on my trackpad... |
Short guide (I'm on Lion 10.7.4. and it works);
You can now run synergy with gestures working.. hopefully! |
Patch works perfectly! Thanks so much! |
Can't wait until this is released as I am having the same issue - all gestures are lost when running Synergy. |
I'm getting a 404 when trying to download the diff per comment on Jun29. Any update on either making the patch available or getting it in the beta release? |
Synergy 1.4.9 on Win7 Home -Client |
@john Blinking, Any chance you could share the patched file? Was excited to see a new release of 1.4.9 today, but disappointed that this patch wasn't implemented =( |
@sean Burdick Thank you for this patch! Worked like a charm with 1.4.9. |
Applied in r1547 (thanks to Bo Jordan). Sean, sorry that you were disappointed. We did some really experimental stuff in 1.4.9 and I didn't want to destabilize the release even more, so no patches went in sadly. I have applied the patch to 1.4.10, so tomorrow you can get access to it via the nightly builds: http://synergy-foss.org/nightly/ |
@nickbolton awesome! thanks =) |
Applied in r1547 (thanks to Bo Jordan). Sean, sorry that you were disappointed. We did some really experimental stuff in 1.4.9 and I didn't want to destabilize the release even more, so no patches went in sadly. I have applied the patch to 1.4.10, so tomorrow you can get access to it via the nightly builds: http://synergy-foss.org/nightly/ This version has corrected the issue.. And is working great in OSX 10.8 This also fixed the the side scrolling forward and back locking up safari tabs. Great work.. |
|
Bump again, I was painfully living with this when I had a PC as my client, but now that I have a second mac as my synergy client, it further pains me to understand that this is still an unresolved issue. |
|
As this issue was originally opened against OSX Lion, I would like to confirm that 3.5 years later this is still an issue on High Sierra & Mojave DB 4 -- of course I understand Mojave will be "unsupported" until it's official public release in September. |
|
It’s actually an issue from 2011, as you can see in the first post.. it’s just imported to github, so, more like 7 years. |
|
Also still an issue on El Capitan 10.11.6 :( |
|
Hopping on the "this would be great to have" train |
|
Lol @metac0rtex just give up man, I think we all did like 3 years ago.
…On Tue, Oct 30, 2018 at 9:09 AM metac0rtex ***@***.***> wrote:
Hopping on the "this would be great to have" train
—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#2905 (comment)>,
or mute the thread
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AQt8kAytw-ukDxkGuOIfVE_PmVtoI2ryks5uqGuagaJpZM4Ct4KG>
.
|
|
I don't understand why teleport can do this but no others can |
Is the teleport working between two MacBooks? I run on Catalina10.15.2 |
|
Works fine for me, after finally setting it up |
Would you have any tips on how to make it run? The latest version 1.2.1 I've found here: https://github.com/abyssoft/teleport/releases After opening it and allowing in Security & Privacy it doesn't do anything. It would help me tremendously making it work. |
|
I recently installed Synergy and like everyone else here, I was baffled and disappointed to find that gestures were unavailable on my client computer. (Honestly... the copyright for Symless in the about screen is from 2012, and multi-touch gestures have been around longer than that.) Anyway, I went to the helpdesk to request a refund an I noticed this post: I know there are a lot of frustrated comments on this thread saying they gave up on waiting to see Synergy support gestures, but is this helpdesk post an acknowledgement that progress is actually being made on this issue? If so, is this expected as and update to v1 or part of the 2023 release? I ask because like some other people here, I have tried Teleport (which is FOSS, but abandonware) and... despite the lag, the gestures support means I can use my client Mac like a Mac, and I don't have to change my workflow. I would much rather give $40 to a project that is in active development and sees regular releases but this is an absolute dealbreaker for me. Is there actually an update on this? |
|
I gave up and went to ShareMouse. Bit more $ - but it works. JMTC
https://www.sharemouse.com/
…Sent from my iPhone
On Jul 10, 2020, at 22:51, Ian Del Giudice ***@***.***> wrote:
I recently installed Synergy and like everyone else here, I was baffled and disappointed to find that gestures were unavailable on my client computer. (Honestly... the copyright for Symless in the about screen is from 2012, and multi-touch gestures have been around longer than that.)
Anyway, I went to the helpdesk to request a refund an I noticed this post:
https://support.symless.com/hc/en-us/articles/360007326057-macOS-Gestures-Support-and-Special-Mouse-combo-keys
Promising multi touch support eventually... but it's dated July 9th (yesterday) and says that gestures "are in our roadmap"
I know there are a lot of frustrated comments on this thread saying they gave up on waiting to see Synergy support gestures, but is this helpdesk post an acknowledgement that progress is actually being made on this issue? If so, is this expected as and update to v1 or part of the 2023 release?
I ask because like some other people here, I have tried Teleport (which is FOSS, but abandonware) and... despite the lag, the gestures support means I can use my client Mac like a Mac, and I don't have to change my workflow. I would much rather give $40 to a project that is in active development and sees regular releases but this is an absolute dealbreaker for me.
Is there actually an update on this?
—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.
|
|
Bump for trackpad gestures support |
|
I checked with the creators of ShareMouse - and they said that they could support only the 2 finger gestures to rotate and zoom. Other gestures weren't possible as the OS doesn't make them available. So it appears that -- after waiting 7 years for this to get fixed on Synergy -- this might not even be possible??? "Does ShareMouse support trackpad gestures? ShareMouse supports two finger gestures to rotate and zoom. Multi-finger gestures are not supported at this time as the OS doesn't seem to allow reading out such commands. We will continue to monitor the situation and try to implement multi-finger gestures if possible." |
|
Just gotta reverse engineer how Apple's Screen Sharing app does it... Can't be that hard right? 😹 |
|
teleport is free and supports gestures for everything. its even working on my macos11 beta. BIG props to whomever the genius is who wrote it. |
|
Agreed, teleport works
On September 26, 2020, khayrab ***@***.***> wrote:
teleport is free and supports gestures for everything. its even
working on my macos11 beta. BIG props to whomever the genius is who
wrote it.
—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#2905 (comment)-
699274158>, or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-
auth/AALBUP2QISLAEOLJCNTDM7TSHVEVBANCNFSM4AVXQKDA>.
|
|
ShareMouse isn't free. Isn't cheap. But it does work, and I use it daily.
Symless will never work IMHO.
Teleport worked - ShareMouse was better for my needs.
<bow>
…Sent from my iPad
On Sep 25, 2020, at 9:12 PM, Javier Matusevich ***@***.***> wrote:
Agreed, teleport works
On September 26, 2020, khayrab ***@***.***> wrote:
> teleport is free and supports gestures for everything. its even
> working on my macos11 beta. BIG props to whomever the genius is who
> wrote it.
>
—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#2905 (comment)-
699274158>, or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-
auth/AALBUP2QISLAEOLJCNTDM7TSHVEVBANCNFSM4AVXQKDA>.
—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.
|
|
I will try teleport |
|
Yey! - looks like our 10 year wait to share gestures across apple devices is nearly over -- Mac OS Monterey & iOS 15 will allow seamless sharing across Macs, iPads (& ?iPhones ) as a core OS feature later this year. |
|
Yeah but how many functionalities will be stripped out in macOS Monterey
(sounds cheesy to me)? I don't even want Big Sur, there are so many
limitations and dropped features. :'(
*Connor A. PurcellCAP Artwork & Designwww.capartwork.com
<http://www.capartwork.com>*
*www.society6.com/capartwork <http://www.facebook.com/capartwork>*
…On Wed, Jun 9, 2021 at 4:32 AM Richard Allen ***@***.***> wrote:
Yey! - looks like our 10 year wait to share gestures across apple devices
is nearly over -- Mac OS Monterey & iOS 15 will allow seamless sharing
across Macs, iPads (& ?iPhones ) as a core OS feature later this year.
—
You are receiving this because you commented.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#2905 (comment)>,
or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADFJQPSXKYARDZ2QI7FIFG3TR4RKXANCNFSM4AVXQKDA>
.
|
ghost
mentioned this issue
|
Proper workaround for now is to use keyboard shortcuts:
Other keyboard shortcuts are listed at Mac keyboard shortcuts. |
and others
Imported issue:
Steps to reproduce:
Expected: Missioncontrol or Launchpad to open
Actual: Nothing happened.
Versions (Synergy, OS):
Server: Mac OS 10.7 Lion - Synergy Pro 1.35RC w/ QSynergy
Client 1: Mac OS 10.7 Lion - Synergy Pro 1.35RC w/ QSynergy
Workaround:
Nope... anything other than mouse clicks do not work. I would love to see multitouch gestures supported.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: