Pedestrian route not using shorter paths in park

[andrixnet]

Describe your problem!

Trying to route to cache using walk profiles doesn't use pedestrian features.

How to reproduce?

I am in a park. There are several paths in the park. There is a cache outside the park and walking, the shortest part is using such paths.
c:geo with internal routing or external BRouter app (tested with both).
Using walk profile.

Actual result after these steps?

I get the same route as if using car profile. The routing doesn't go through the park.

As a comparison, routing using OSMAND does use the paths with walk profile, and it also uses basically the same data.

Expected result after these steps?

Route using the pedestrian paths.

Reproducible

Yes

c:geo Version

2024.04.13

System information

## System information

c:geo version: 2024.04.13

Device:- Device type: SM-G965F (star2ltexx, samsung)
- Available processors: 8
- Android version: 9
- Android build: PPR1.180610.011.G965FXXS7CSK4
- Screen resolution: 1440x2792px (411x773dp)
- Pixel density: 3.8500001
- System font scale: 1.1 / used scale: 1.1
- Sailfish OS detected: false
- Google Play services: enabled - 24.12.17 (100400-623887440)
- Memory: Available:2.2 GB, Total:5.5 GB, Threshold: 216.0 MB, low:false

Sensor and location:- Low power mode: inactive
- Compass capabilities: yes
- Rotation vector sensor: present
- Orientation sensor: present
- Magnetometer & Accelerometer sensor: present
- Direction sensor used: rotation vector

Program settings:- Settings: v9, Count:220
- Set language: en_GB (system default)
- System date format: dd/MM/y
- Time zone: GMT+03:00
- Debug mode active: no
- Log Settings: debug=false, minLevel=WARN, minAddCallerInfo=NONE, addCallerInfoMaxDepth=8, throwOnError=false, transactionSizes=false
- Last manual backup: 4 Nov 2022, 16:42
- Last auto backup: 6 Apr, 08:59
- Routing mode: Walk
- Live map mode: false
- Use unified map: false
- OSM multi-threading: true / threads: 4
- Map: Romania (Offline)
- Id: cgeo.geocaching.maps.mapsforge.MapsforgeMapProvider$OfflineMapSource:primary:maps/mapsforge/Romania.map
- Atts: Map data (c) OpenStreetMap contributors
- Theme: none

Filters:- Hide waypoints: -
- LIVE: Origin: geocaching.com, Status: Exclude Archived ({"advanced":true,"inconclusive":false,"tree":{"type":"AND","children":[{"type":"stored_list","config":{}},{"type":"origin","config":{"values":["geocaching.com"]}},{"type":"status","config":{"values":["exclude_archived"]}}]}})
- OFFLINE: None ({"advanced":true,"inconclusive":false,"tree":{"type":"AND","children":[{"type":"origin","config":{}},{"type":"status","config":{}}]}})

Services:- Geocaching sites enabled:
- geocaching.com: Not logged in (Logging in…)
- opencaching.ro: Logged in (Login OK)
- Geocaching.com date format: yyyy-MM-dd
- Geocaching.com website language: en-US
- Last login error on geocaching.com: failed to find request verification token (2024-04-14 13-07)
- Last successful login on geocaching.com: 2024-04-14 13-45
- Routing: external / BRouter installed: true

Permissions- ACCESS_COARSE_LOCATION: granted
- ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION: granted
- READ_CONTACTS: DENIED
- WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE: granted
- POST_NOTIFICATIONS: granted

Paths- System internal c:geo dir: /data/user/0/cgeo.geocaching (170.2 GB free) v3 internal isDir(10 entries)
- Legacy User storage c:geo dir: /storage/emulated/0/cgeo (170.2 GB free) v3 external non-removable isDir(7 entries)
- Geocache data: /storage/emulated/0/Android/data/cgeo.geocaching/files/GeocacheData (170.2 GB free) v3 external non-removable isDir(568 entries)
- Internal theme sync (is turned off): /data/user/0/cgeo.geocaching/MapThemeData (170.2 GB free) v3 internal isDir(0 entries)
- Map render theme path:
- Public Folders: #12
- BASE: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo (av:true, files:>=26, size:>=305.5 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- OFFLINE_MAPS: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:maps/mapsforge/document/primary:maps/mapsforge (av:true, files:>=6, size:>=825.4 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- OFFLINE_MAP_THEMES: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:maps/mapsforge/document/primary:maps/mapsforge (av:true, files:>=6, size:>=825.4 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- OFFLINE_MAP_SHADING: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:maps/mapsforge/document/primary:maps/mapsforge/_hgt (av:true, files:>=0, size:>=0 B, free:>=170.2 GB)
- LOGFILES: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/logfiles (av:true, files:>=2, size:>=247.4 KB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- GPX: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:gpx/document/primary:gpx (av:true, files:>=4, size:>=3.4 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- BACKUP: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/backup (av:true, files:>=28, size:>=308.2 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- FIELD_NOTES: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/field-notes (av:true, files:>=0, size:>=0 B, free:>=170.2 GB)
- SPOILER_IMAGES: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/GeocachePhotos (av:true, files:>=0, size:>=0 B, free:>=170.2 GB)
- ROUTING_BASE: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/routing (av:true, files:>=10, size:>=78.9 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- ROUTING_TILES: content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo/document/primary:cgeo/routing/segments4 (av:true, files:>=2, size:>=78.8 MB, free:>=170.2 GB)
- TEST_FOLDER: file:///data/user/0/cgeo.geocaching/files/unittest (av:true, files:>=0, size:>=0 B, free:>=170.2 GB)
- PersistedDocumentUris: #2
- PROXIMITY_NOTIFICATION_FAR: null
- PROXIMITY_NOTIFICATION_CLOSE: null
- Persisted Uri Permissions: #3
- content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:maps/mapsforge (19 Apr 2021, 11:32):RW
- content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:gpx (19 Apr 2021, 11:32):RW
- content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary:cgeo (19 Apr 2021, 11:32):RW
- Database: /storage/emulated/0/Android/data/cgeo.geocaching/files/databases/data (v103, Size:12.5 MB) on user storage

--- End of system information ---

-- 
Sent from my Android phone with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.

Additional Information

No response

[moving-bits]

It may be that c:geo is not using an actual walking profile. As written in #15620 (comment): Can you please go to settings => routing/navigation and check what profiles you have configured for walk / bike / car?

[andrixnet]

When checking "use internal routing" I see the following:

• "walk" profile - shortest.brf
• "bike" profile - trekking.brf
• "car" profile - car-eco.brf

[andrixnet]

Note: I have updated over the weekend to 2024.04.18 version.
In a different location (city), in a park, it routed for me through the alleys of the park, in the context of the external BRouter. (same context as the initial report here, context which later I changed to internal routing for test purposes).

I will try to revisit the place on which this report was based and get back.

[fm-sys]

Maybe the park is just not correctly mapped in OSM...?

[andrixnet]

Unlikely, using OSMAnd and walk profile I get route through park alleys.

[andrixnet]

Interesting. Revisited the place today, tested with both internal routing and with external BRouter app and it worked both ways.
c:geo version 2024.04.25 (no other changes, same maps)

[andrixnet]

I'd say it's safe to close this.

[moving-bits]

That's indeed strange, we have changed nothing wrt to routing in the last versions... But anyway, thanks for cross-checking and reporting back.