Bug: Claudie doesn't allow nodes from two different AWS provider instances in the same region

[bernardhalas]

Current Behaviour

Currently, Claudie doesn't allow the following configuration:

spec:
  providers:
    - name: aws-team1
      providerType: aws
...
    - name: aws-team2
      providerType: aws
...
  nodePools:
    dynamic:
      - name: control-aws
        providerSpec:
          name: aws-team1
          region: eu-west-1
      - name: compute-aws
        providerSpec:
          name: aws-team2
          region: eu-west-1

Expected Behaviour

Sometimes, the users might want to deploy nodepools in the same region, by two different providers (e.g. for billing, reporting or security issues).

Anything else to note

Currently, I see the options to set provider.alias to e.g.:

• nodepool_{{ $provider.name }}_{{ $provider.region }}
• nodepool_{{ substr(sha256($provider.name + $provider.region), 0, 4) }}
• nodepool_{{ $random }}

References

• Bug: Claudie doesn't support multiple Provider configurations for the same cloud provider #1296
• https://github.com/berops/claudie/blob/master/services/terraformer/templates/aws/provider.tpl

[JKBGIT1]

Depends on #1296