Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Undesirable discharge characterizations that block veterans' access to benefits #23

Open
JeffL-T opened this issue Dec 6, 2016 · 6 comments

Comments

@JeffL-T
Copy link

JeffL-T commented Dec 6, 2016

Undesirable Discharge Characterizations (general discharges and below) can block veterans from receiving valuable treatment and compensation benefits to which they would otherwise be entitled (e.g. PTSD treatment and compensation). Many discharge characterizations were based on performance issues that now warrant reconsideration as service-connected PTSD, in accordance with the “PTSD Upgrade Memo” from the Secretary of Defense in 2014. Between 9% and 21% of veterans may qualify for benefits such as service-connected disability treatment, related compensation, healthcare, and the option of pioneering Veterans Treatment Courts (VTC) as alternate routes to justice. Personal appearances are allowed at Discharge Review Boards (DRB), but the boards are held almost exclusively in Washington DC at the veteran's expense. An online hearing process would allow an opportunity for personal appearances by those veterans that find travel to the DRB cost-prohibitive.

2014/15 fiscal Data:
Honorable: 78.29 percent
General – Under Honorable Conditions: 6.36 percent
Under Other Than Honorable Conditions: 2.09 percent
Bad Conduct: 0.49 percent
Dishonorable: 0.07 percent
Total = 9%, or 21% when considering uncharacterized or unknown.

@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Upgrade discharge characterizations that are resulting in legal bars to veterans’ benefits. Upgrade discharge characterizations that result in legal bars to veterans’ benefits. Dec 6, 2016
@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Upgrade discharge characterizations that result in legal bars to veterans’ benefits. Upgrade discharge characterizations that hinder veterans’ access to benefits. Dec 7, 2016
@christyleos christyleos changed the title Upgrade discharge characterizations that hinder veterans’ access to benefits. Upgrade discharge characterizations that hinder veterans’ access to benefits Dec 7, 2016
@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Upgrade discharge characterizations that hinder veterans’ access to benefits Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which prevent access to care and benefits Dec 7, 2016
@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which prevent access to care and benefits Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which block veters' access to care and benefits Dec 7, 2016
@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which block veters' access to care and benefits Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which block veterans' access to benefits Dec 7, 2016
@JeffL-T
Copy link
Author

JeffL-T commented Dec 8, 2016

PTSD prevalence: Vietnam-15%, Gulf War-11%-20%, OIF/OEF 12%. Source is VA: http://www.ptsd.va.gov/public/PTSD-overview/basics/how-common-is-ptsd.asp

@JeffL-T
Copy link
Author

JeffL-T commented Dec 8, 2016

...certain specific benefits, such as GI Bill education benefits, are only reserved for service members who receive an honorable discharge.

You are not likely to be eligible to receive any veteran benefits if you receive an [Other Than Honorable] discharge, but the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) will examine the circumstances of your OTH discharge to determine whether you're eligible or not.

http://military-law.lawyers.com/veterans-benefits/discharges-and-their-effect-on-veteran-benefits.html

@JeffL-T JeffL-T changed the title Undesirable discharge characterizations (e.g. dishonorable) which block veterans' access to benefits Undesirable discharge characterizations that block veterans' access to benefits Jan 8, 2017
@christyleos
Copy link
Member

Current "tools" for discharge upgrades:

@kautif
Copy link

kautif commented Feb 24, 2017

So, to be honest, this is unfamiliar territory for me. I'm interested in hearing what the process would be for a veteran in terms of making an online personal appearance and then the process for pitching that to DRB (correct?)

@JeffL-T
Copy link
Author

JeffL-T commented Feb 24, 2017

Swords to Ploughshares have a section called How do the Boards operate? that explains the Personal Appearance Review process in very good detail. One way to pitch an online process to the DRB might be that it would relieve the travel burden to the veteran and also allow panel members to conveniently meet from their own offices. There would likely be no need for equipment procurement, but support would be a consideration.

@JeffL-T
Copy link
Author

JeffL-T commented Mar 8, 2017

The BIG IDEA is to build an AV platform for remote personal appearances before the DRB, that allows submission of a list of issues for DRB consideration; documentary evidence, such as doctor statements, school diplomas, character references, and documents promoting clemency (for punitive discharges); be recordable; allow panel members to attend the board remotely from their workstations; allow veterans representative (likely an attorney) to attend from their workstation; allow instant messaging and caucus between veteran and their representative; allow all documents before the board to be shared with the veteran and their representative.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants