Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add the ability to switch between acrylic and explorer blur on windows 10 #51

Closed
windowsxp3790 opened this issue Jan 25, 2024 · 9 comments
Labels
enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@windowsxp3790
Copy link

windowsxp3790 commented Jan 25, 2024

In a discord server we did some testing and found that acrylic can perform better in some ways then explorer blur on windows 10
Other than acrylic only updating at 30fps or whatever it's better becuse at least it doesn't progressively slow down your window movement the more windows you have open
Only having 6/7 windows open is enough for explorerblur to already become slow as hell for just dragging things around while acrylic is locked at 30fps no matter how many windows you have open
So basically acrylic is just more consistent in performance

@windowsxp3790 windowsxp3790 changed the title Add the ability to switch between acrylic and explorer blur Add the ability to switch between acrylic and explorer blur on windows 10 Jan 25, 2024
@Maplespe
Copy link
Owner

Maplespe commented Jan 26, 2024

As I've said many times, Acrylic simply doesn't work, not only does it have no effect in 22H2 but the drag delay is 100x slower than Blur.
Obviously you haven't done any actual testing or development.
Acrylic for UWP is fine, but this is a Win32 app.

But where you do a search you get tons of reports of this problem.
https://www.google.com/search?q=windows+acrylic+lag

tauri-apps/window-vibrancy#47 Windows Acrylic effect lag

seo-rii/electron-acrylic-window#6 lag

EYHN/vscode-vibrancy#5 Problem drag, move window by Title Bar

This is my last reply to this issue, here is a video of the actual test:

Desktop 2024.01.26.mp4.zip

We're already working on custom blur, and there's no use in rushing.

@ALTaleX531 ALTaleX531 added the enhancement New feature or request label Jan 26, 2024
@TheInsane101
Copy link

We're already working on custom blur, and there's no use in rushing.

Does that you mean you are developing a new shader like Big Muscle did with Glass8? If so, that is absolutely amazing! If not, that's fine too!

@Maplespe
Copy link
Owner

Maplespe commented Feb 4, 2024

Does that you mean you are developing a new shader like Big Muscle did with Glass8? If so, that is absolutely amazing! If not, that's fine too!

Yes, not only that, but it's no exaggeration to say that it's also more powerful than glass8's effect, which will be unprecedented.

@ALTaleX531
Copy link
Collaborator

Not a shader, to exact, but our own implementation of the blurring method😊, which is still very different from Glass 8 ( btw: Glass 8 uses not a shader, but a reproduction of the Windows 7 blurring mechanism).
Here's a preview of what you might be interested in.😎
image

@TheInsane101
Copy link

Not a shader, to exact, but our own implementation of the blurring method😊, which is still very different from Glass 8 ( btw: Glass 8 uses not a shader, but a reproduction of the Windows 7 blurring mechanism). Here's a preview of what you might be interested in.😎 image

Tbh I don't see the difference compared to the current version (I don't use Windows 11 so I don't know what the current 11 version looks like) but I like the shadow borders. The ability to extend the effect into entire windows looks so cool though! Excited! Btw you're being quite nice; I appreciate it 😊

Will the reflection also be layered on top of the colour layer (so it's more visible) and have its movement mimic Windows 7's more accurately?

@Maplespe
Copy link
Owner

Maplespe commented Feb 4, 2024

This image should be more obvious:
The Aero reflection is at the very top, and the inactive window also has the exposure and saturation effects of Aero (which is the real Aero effect).
195131

@TheInsane101
Copy link

This image should be more obvious: The Aero reflection is at the very top, and the inactive window also has the exposure and saturation effects of Aero (which is the real Aero effect). 195131

Oh now I can see it much better. It looks fantastic and exactly like Windows 7's Aero! I wish you so much luck with this!😍

@TorutheRedFox
Copy link

This image should be more obvious: The Aero reflection is at the very top, and the inactive window also has the exposure and saturation effects of Aero (which is the real Aero effect). 195131

oh nice

@Maplespe
Copy link
Owner

Maplespe commented Feb 6, 2024

Updated in the new version.

@Maplespe Maplespe closed this as completed Feb 6, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

5 participants