Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Website and forum are down #417

Open
jonisb opened this issue Dec 26, 2022 · 83 comments
Open

Website and forum are down #417

jonisb opened this issue Dec 26, 2022 · 83 comments
Labels

Comments

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator

jonisb commented Dec 26, 2022

I'm trying to reply to this post XBMC2 tread but get this error:
EventGhost forum error

jonib

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Dec 31, 2022

Still getting this error. I don't see any new posts on the forum so don't know if it works for anyone else.
I tried with Pale moon and Edge browsers.

@ThomasBott
Copy link
Contributor

I can confirm, same problem for me.. @kdschlosser: can you help?

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Dec 31, 2022

Thanks for confirming, I was helping a user and have no idea if his issue got resolved 😭

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Jan 2, 2023

Looks like http://www.eventghost.net is completely dead now. 🖖

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 2, 2023

The server isn't responding to ping's so I'm afraid it's down. I tought it was hosted by https://joesdatacenter.com/.
At least the last one I had access to before the last server move (end march/2020?) was located there and I think Kevin stayed with them.
Kevin didn't respond to the mail I've sent him to his private address, but with the holidays and all it might take a while.
I've reached out to joesdatacenter and asked for a reboot if possible. Not sure if it's going to result in anything, as I am a stranger to them.

I've noticed the previous server is still up and I my access hasn't been revoked so I'm currently making backups of the data as it was on march/2020 - you never know.

@packetwarrior
Copy link

The server isn't responding to ping's so I'm afraid it's down. I tought it was hosted by https://joesdatacenter.com/. At least the last one I had access to before the last server move (end march/2020?) was located there and I think Kevin stayed with them. Kevin didn't respond to the mail I've sent him to his private address, but with the holidays and all it might take a while. I've reached out to joesdatacenter and asked for a reboot if possible. Not sure if it's going to result in anything, as I am a stranger to them.

I've noticed the previous server is still up and I my access hasn't been revoked so I'm currently making backups of the data as it was on march/2020 - you never know.

Did you ever end up hearing back from Joe's Datacenter? It looks like the current IP address eventghost.net resolves to is still allocated to them.

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 5, 2023

No - they did not respond yet. I'm currently Github stalking @kdschlosser for attention. I've posted a response to the last 2 issues he opened yesterday.

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Jan 15, 2023

I'TS ALIVE or almost I was able to half load the EventGhost forum so it seems the server is not completely dead.
But refreshing to get it fully loaded it again died, no idea what this means, but if there is life there is hope 🙏
Edit: I probably was loading some cached version of the page as its current date was dec 31

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 15, 2023

At this point I'm not that hopeful anymore:

  • I contacted https://joesdatacenter.com/ on two occasions but got no response, which as I am not a customer nor do I have the correct customer information is understandable.
  • I combed trough the last forum database backup that I have (March 2020):
    • Found Kevin's gmail address: send two emails a couple of days apart - no response (yet?)
    • Found his wife's Denise hotmail address, sent an email - no response (yet?)
    • Found a phone number, called twice (different days) no pickup, has no voicemail configured. sent and sms, used the carriers email2phone service, sent a whatsapp - no response (yet?)
  • Commented off-topic on 2 by Kevin recently opened Github issues, got no response but he responded on a later comment posted on one of these issues so I'm pretty sure he saw my post.
  • Used the contact option on the eventghost.net whois info in order to contact the owner which I know for sure is Kevin - no response (yet?) - registration is expiring 18 Januari 2023 - hope this does not elapse

Then I went full "stalker" (for which I'm not proud), using the phone number I found:

  • Confirmed this number is indeed registered to Kevin
  • Found an accompanying home address - indeed in the Rockies as his github profile suggests
  • Found the land line number for that address, called it, got message spoken by Denise, left a voicemail - no response (yet?)

There is an eventghost slack channel but I deleted my account on that a couple of years back and I can't get back in. Maybe someone else could try to reach out to Kevin there?

I'm currently out of further ideas.

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 16, 2023

I may be grasping at straws but I've sent a mail to @Pako2 @CarsonF @topic2k and Zian in the hope @kdschlosser shared the server information with one of them, and we can get things running again.

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Jan 16, 2023

Thanks for your efforts dequi, hopefully this is not the end of EventGhost.

@CarsonF
Copy link
Contributor

CarsonF commented Jan 16, 2023

I'm happy to give anyone access to GitHub.
I don't have any idea about the website/forum. All of this is so old and unmaintained.
I'm not even sure what this offers anymore that Home Assistant doesn't.

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 16, 2023

@CarsonF could you possibly give access to jonisb and me, then we can start from there. If @jonisb could recommend one or two others then at least we are with three or four.

I got back here at the newyears because I was looking for automation software for some business related tasks on Windows pc and EventGhost was the first that came to mind as somewhat familiar. On the home end I use Node Red on a Synology NAS but I need something to be rooted in WIndows. Don't know why others are here but I'm sure they have their reasons.

@CarsonF
Copy link
Contributor

CarsonF commented Jan 16, 2023

@CarsonF could you possibly give access to jonisb and me, then we can start from there.

Done.

I'd recommend migrating the website to host from GitHub to keep it here and simplify access and everything.

I'd recommend migrating the forum to GitHub discussions for the same reason.

@Ian-Zz
Copy link

Ian-Zz commented Jan 17, 2023

This is Ian aka zian. First saw this thread last week or so when I noticed eg.net no longer loaded. I have zero recent knowledge or data concerning the site, domain, hosting etc. Have not seen KG post recently on FB. Have not spoke to him direct in maybe years.
Would so hate to lose all that shared knowledge over years and years. Will try to ping KG myself. Willing to do what it takes to save that forum and all its data.
Thanks to all working on the same.

@Ian-Zz
Copy link

Ian-Zz commented Jan 17, 2023

No Shit. An Update.
I just checked my old seldom logged into email account and did a quick "evenghost" search. Came up with an email from support@domain-inc.net sent to me on 9-19-22.

It says in jist.... my details removed....
Dear Valued Customer,

ICANN, the organization responsible for the stability of the Internet,
requires that each domain name registrant be given the opportunity to
correct any inaccurate contact data (WHOIS data) associated with a domain
name registration. Our records for your domain are as follows:
eventghost.net

Domain Name: EVENTGHOST.NET
Registry Domain ID:
Registrar WHOIS Server: whois.domain.com
Registrar URL: www.domain.com
Updated Date: 2020-01-21T14:32:23
Creation Date: 2011-01-18T22:59:52
Registrar Registration Expiration Date: 2023-01-18T22:59:52
Reseller: Domain.com
Domain Status: ok https://icann.org/epp#ok
Registry Registrant ID:
Registrant Name: Ian

I followed the links in the email and logged in to domain.com and have the chance to renew the Domain Name: EVENTGHOST.NET for another year for $19.95 2 3 4 5YEARS FOR $99.95. Looks to me like we only have 3 days to ACT (at least on this domain name) portion of whatever the deal is with Eventghost.net going on now. Would just hate to pay $20 or $100 for something that isn't the main part of our problem.

Why is the site no longer loading? Anyone 100% certain why?
Thanks. Ian Feel free to email me. I'll hope to check it soon. er. Maybe.

@per1234
Copy link
Collaborator

per1234 commented Jan 17, 2023

I don't use EventGhost anymore, but I'll contribute towards the domain registration fee if needed.

@LoganAC34
Copy link

I don't use EventGhost anymore, but I'll contribute towards the domain registration fee if needed.

I use event ghost all the time. I'll contribute too.

@jonisb
Copy link
Collaborator Author

jonisb commented Jan 17, 2023

@Ian-Zz Renewing the domain at least for a year should be fine, $20 Kickstarter lets goo 😸

@Ian-Zz
Copy link

Ian-Zz commented Jan 17, 2023

Well whatever the problem is with the website we now have another year to fix it. At least in respect to the domain portion. I just purchased a years worth of all that's listed below at domain.com.
eventghost.net
1 Year
Domain $19.99 Renews 01/16/24
1 Year Privacy + Protection $8.99 Renews 01/16/24

1 Year Domain Expiration Protection $9.99
Subtotal $38.97 Sales Tax$2.34
Total $41.31

@CarsonF
Copy link
Contributor

CarsonF commented Jan 17, 2023

@Ian-Zz you want to be an org owner here too?

@ThomasBott
Copy link
Contributor

I'm also happy to support the project on git side; still using EventGhost at the office and for home automation and it's working great! I'm much to invested to change to another tool

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 17, 2023

hopefully this is not the end of EventGhost.

I would say we are off life-support, and into intensive care I guess. Still lack of basic motor functions and big memory loss but still viable.

  • Get access to the EventGhost GitHub organisation/repository for multiple members - Thanks @CarsonF
  • Get access to a EventGhost.net domain owner and get it renewed - Thanks @Ian-Zz
  • Get access to the forum data - I only have the data until March 2020 - missing almost 3 years worth of knowledge
    I'm still hoping @kdschlosser responds back with the joesdatacenter info or a more more recent backup.
  • Get access to the old EventGhost website/docs data - I have these / can be regenerated
  • Get access to the old EventGhost wiki data - I have these

@dequi
Copy link
Contributor

dequi commented Jan 17, 2023

I'm also happy to support the project on git side;

@ThomasBott as you were quick to respond to jonisb 's post and already have contributed in the past. I deem you invested and worthy. 😄
I've sent you an invite. Now the burden is shared.

@Ian-Zz
Copy link

Ian-Zz commented Jan 17, 2023

About that. We got pretty lucky with the domain situation. I had no clue that the domain info was still attached to me. I thought it was all changed over years ago at the time of the 2nd EG.net "remodeling".

That being said I think it would be very wise for me to "let go" of this domain and the account. Not sure how it works or if it's transferrable to another party (or two... or three). But seems the smart thing to do.

I know we went through this similar scenario years back. Who holds the keys. Who does and owns what. Who has access etc. But the way it's been the last few weeks (site down) and many viewers willing and able to do what needs to be done to get it back up again asap but looks to be... One man gone = site down = nothing "we" can do. THAT SUCKS. Should be changed for in perpetuity.

I know the bunch of you are very much more familiar with all kinds of tech. Web, ESP, Python Etc Etc Etc. I'm not a coder and I for sure ain't the office keeping type. I shouldn't be in charge of shit. lol

Aren't there any tools or resources for running a website/forum/code base that is handled by a group or community of sorts. One that can also change and evolve over time. Always has many (or at least a few) competent controllers.

And thanks again to all of you chiming in and typing up. 'Specialy dequi and joni and others. I know you all spent years and lots and lots of time taking care of this project and it's users. For that we are all in debt. And that goes tripply for Kevin. The dudes been amazing. 'Till just recently. lol

Come on Kev. Where you at Bro?
Hope your well wherever you are.

@CarsonF
Copy link
Contributor

CarsonF commented Jan 17, 2023

Domains can be transferred, yes. I'd recommend creating a private org repo specifically for these org related secrets and private access info. DNS shared account login, etc. That way any member of the org can login and maintain. That still assumes all good actors obv. I'd recommend Cloudflare for standalone DNS.

@Ian-Zz
Copy link

Ian-Zz commented Jan 17, 2023

CarsonF, Yes yes and yes.
I think I looked into .org last time back. Not sure why it was or wasn't done.

Again I'll say this. Back at the first EG change over 2011 I think. I was working with dns_forwards and names and such. Think I borked it in minutes the first few times. Same with the forum data. Close calls at least. Keep me away from any codes and/or any "high level registering" type shit. The forum anti-bot measures... That I could do. I think I was good at that one.

EG.net Forum... we miss you.
:(

@dequi dequi self-assigned this Jan 20, 2023
@krambriw
Copy link

krambriw commented Jun 7, 2023

I'm sure there is, you have even better possibilities & flexibility. Exactly these type of questions are perfect to put on the forum and a lot of experts and experienced users will welcome you. One thing is most of the time true, if you are looking for something, most likely others have done the same and might already have a solution. The more detailed you can be, the best chance to get a good & useful response

@wysocki
Copy link

wysocki commented Jun 19, 2023

Node-Red appears to be HUGELY more difficult to use than EG. Non-starter in my book.
So, what (if anything) is happening with the restoration of the EG forum/site?

@Soupy51
Copy link

Soupy51 commented Jun 19, 2023 via email

@krambriw
Copy link

krambriw commented Jun 20, 2023

Node-Red appears to be HUGELY more difficult to use than EG

Difficult no, different yes. But it will depend on what your use cases are. Remember EG was originally developed mainly to integrate video/audio/remote control stuff and then expanded in various directions. So if it is that you are looking for, yes EG had such stuff out-of-the-box where Node-RED is a more generic framework with thousands of add-ons, some suppporting video/audio equipment. Even supported by some manufacturers like Samsung. Never saw that happen with EG
https://flows.nodered.org/node/node-red-contrib-samsung-automation-studio-nodes
https://flows.nodered.org/node/node-red-contrib-samsung-tv-control

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

DanEdens commented Jul 6, 2023

I have a dream of rewriting eventghost to use mojo. Anyone interested?

@gorman42
Copy link

gorman42 commented Jul 7, 2023

I have a dream of rewriting eventghost to use mojo. Anyone interested?

Anything that could bring EventGhost back in action would me most welcome! But I'm sadly no developer...

@wysocki
Copy link

wysocki commented Jul 7, 2023

Anything to bring back EG! Actually Mojo appears to be a great new language that combines the usability of Python with the performance of C. Since it's so similar to Python, wouldn't it be possible to migrate at least some parts of EG into it? And since Python is an interpretive language wouldn't its source code be easily available (or decompiled)? I'm an old programmer so I may have already lost my mojo, but this would be a very interesting approach (I'd at least help fund it)!

@Telorast
Copy link

Looking for an alternative to EG, seems like there are lots with good hardware support but how do I replace the integrations with Windows software? That seems to be missing from Node-Red, Home Assistant, and others I have looked at. Am I missing something or how do I interact with Windows and other software without EventGhost?

For example I have shortcuts on my phone that sends messages through Tasker with AutoRemote to EG and then on to other programs like DisplayFusion, MediaMonkey, Perfect Keyboard, VoxCommando or various Windows commands like volume control, sound output or putting monitors in standby.

@Soupy51
Copy link

Soupy51 commented Jul 23, 2023 via email

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

There is no comparison to eventghost for windows. I have searched and searched, and nothing is as good, except maybe paid products like UIpath. I will start trying to get the mojo revival going, @kdschlosser if you want to chime in, I'd love that. but Cheers I get it xD

@gorman42
Copy link

There is no comparison to eventghost for windows. I have searched and searched, and nothing is as good, except maybe paid products like UIpath. I will start trying to get the mojo revival going, @kdschlosser if you want to chime in, I'd love that. but Cheers I get it xD

I am no developer but if there is any way for me to help (testing, I don't know what else), I'd be down for it.

If this gets serious and you would accept donations, I would surely be ready to donate for the cause.

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

DanEdens commented Sep 9, 2023

I can't actually begin work on this until the Windows version of Mojo is released, But This is the new fork I will be attempting to convert Eventghost from stackless 2.7 into Mojo. I will also need to see what incapability problems windows 11 will bring, This is going to be a learning experience for me, but I am determined to get this building, and then continue to develop it into something greater. If we can get it to build on mojo, then I will try to start a new forum and get more people involved.

https://github.com/DanEdens/EventGhost-Mojo

@chip33
Copy link

chip33 commented Sep 9, 2023

@DanEdens
In case you dont have it here is the patch that fixes issues in the last release of EventGhost 0.5.0-rc6.
Credit for the patch goes to a community member I chatted with on the forum but cannot recall the name of at the moment.

EventGhost05rc6patch.zip

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

DanEdens commented Sep 9, 2023

Awesome thank you!!

Not sure if I have it or not so I'll compare.
When did this happen? I'm using one of Kevin's WIP versions with some re-themeing
😄
(link just has screenshot, post is about restarting this)
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/danedens_mojo-eventghost-activity-7106076792158842880-yJma?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_android

@chip33
Copy link

chip33 commented Sep 9, 2023

You are welcome!
I can follow your fork on github.
I believe the patch is at least 2 years old but definitely fixes issues that were in rc6.
It does include the last commit from this repository.
I was active on the forum for a while 2 years ago and this patch was made as it was difficult to get changes put into github and released officially. I was chatting with the man who made it and he was developing his own plugins as well.
You can download a copy of what remains of the website using this software.
https://github.com/hartator/wayback-machine-downloader#installation
It comes in at 1.43GB.

I did download a copy a month or so ago but had not looked at it. I just tried to open the forum section and it is blank just using Chrome.
I also have a plugins folder here that contains as many plugins as I could collect at the time.
plugins.zip

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

DanEdens commented Sep 9, 2023

I'll check it out and return any I have that you don't!
The loss of that forum is seriously a great loss.
It was chalk full of the most complicated and educational threads I've ever seen, It's what got me really into Python.😁
Thanks so much for sharing these

@gorman42
Copy link

I can't actually begin work on this until the Windows version of Mojo is released, But This is the new fork I will be attempting to convert Eventghost from stackless 2.7 into Mojo. I will also need to see what incapability problems windows 11 will bring, This is going to be a learning experience for me, but I am determined to get this building, and then continue to develop it into something greater. If we can get it to build on mojo, then I will try to start a new forum and get more people involved.

https://github.com/DanEdens/EventGhost-Mojo

I can't set up a build environment but I will follow development and I am ready to test whatever you'll want to throw my way.

Thanks for providing a glimmer of hope for a future with EventGhost.

@chip33
Copy link

chip33 commented Sep 10, 2023

@DanEdens

I'm using one of Kevin's WIP versions with some re-themeing <

Hi, would it be possible to share the code changes used to create the dark theme UI you show in the image in your post above?

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

Okay so bare with me a little and I'll try to fix it after I explain.

So this was one of the VERY FIRST things I ever learned how to do in python. It was that AHA moment that really turned me into a Python dev. Eventghost was completely open for me to chop to pieces!

But it's sloppy :D Very sloppy. So sloppy that I still have hardcoded hacky paths in my personal copy that won't work for your machine. I have custom menu options and some other weird stuff that wouldn't make sense lol.

That being said. Checkout this commit and I think we can walk you through how to edit it yourself.

DanEdens@4116e4d

@DanEdens
Copy link
Contributor

@chip33 Were you able to play with the colors?

@chip33
Copy link

chip33 commented Sep 12, 2023

Hi Dan,
I swapped out the original RGB values for the new ones in all 3 files
[eg/Classes/MonitorsCtrl.py]
[plugins/System/init.py]
[plugins/Webserver/init.py]
I figured the other changes were just related to the other things you do in that commit.

Initially I had some errors in the log but that was due to incorrect formatting (or encoding).
I was using notepad++ and when redone with Visual Studio Code there are no errors but so far no change in the UI colours.
I will have another look when I have a bit more time.

@SamuelWest
Copy link

Hi @DanEdens I'm a reasonably experienced python dev have written a couple of EG plugins. There's nothing as good as EG for windows, so it'd be terrible if it died! Is there anything in particular that I could help with?

@ThomasBott
Copy link
Contributor

Basically EventGhost needs to be upgraded to python 3 to have a future..

@steffenu
Copy link

steffenu commented Dec 10, 2023

Also created a few Eventghost Plugins back in the day. So im Hoping to see the legacy of Eventghost continue. That being said . I think that will be difficult as it is right now. This Project is probably dead and wont be revived. My EG Chrome Extension were killed and burned along with it by google as the site went down :D.

Updating Eg to Python 3 wont work for a future. Since all plugins are Python 2 based. You could update the core easily. But it would be a empty python 3 shell without any plugins. So just by that you see the vastness of effort required.

At this point it makes sense to make something new. But that requires a good amount of experience. And would be a huge undertaking. Maybe further down the road. I have professional Webdev Experience , long time hobby pythonista and going into State of the Art Software next year.

Im Interisted to see if there are still people willing to dedicate time to this or more likely a new project.
Feel Free to send me mail if you got the passion , time and willingness to pull smth off together. Would be happy to chat about it. Miss the old good days with @DanEdens , @kdschlosser .

@ThomasBott
Copy link
Contributor

Of course the plugins would have to be adjusted as well but without the core running python 3 no plugin dev would update their plugins. Modifying a plugin to work with Python 3 is also no big deal - Someone has to start, I guess :)

@chip33
Copy link

chip33 commented Dec 10, 2023

Updating the plugins to work with Python 3, isn't this just the kind of thing that Chat GPT is good for? It can make mistakes that will need checking but could make it a lot easier.

Modifying a plugin to work with Python 3 is also no big deal

@Telorast
Copy link

With so much lost beyond recovery, a python 3 reboot sound like a good idea. Even with a much reduced plug-in list EventGhost would be an attractive option with some active developers.

Considering how many other options there are for creating the rules behind a smart home now it might make sense to focus more on being the Windows node, passing on events and acting on commands from another system.

@SamRWest
Copy link

SamRWest commented Jan 9, 2024

@DanEdens, @kdschlosser how functional is https://github.com/kdschlosser/EventGhost-x64-Python3.5 at the moment?

After some fiddling with dependencies and installing lots of MS stuff I can build and kind of run it locally, but get a bunch of runtime errors which I think are from some python 2 syntax in the eg packages that are still yet to be translated.

Just wanted to understand whether I'm doing something wrong with the build (entirely possible, NFI how the build script works yet), or if it's actually just not yet functional?

If the latter, any idea how much effort would be required, and is this code a good starting point?

@MP-Munich
Copy link

Is it planned to bring the EventGhost website and forum back online?

I'd love seeing this fabulous application still alive! 😊

@steffenu
Copy link

steffenu commented Jan 23, 2024

Is it planned to bring the EventGhost website and forum back online?

I'd love seeing this fabulous application still alive! 😊

Talked with @DanEdens about this.
I will probably will start create somthing fresh from the ground up . Maybe there will be an announcement this year. Stay tuned :)

( Eventghost is probably dead )

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests