You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I have encountered an issue with the collapsing behavior of consecutive citation numbers in in-text citations when using the bibliography function in Typst. Using the citation style "gb-7714-2015-numeric", the relevant CSL code for citation rendering is as follows:
According to this style, in-text citations should be rendered as superscript numbers enclosed in square brackets, e.g., [1]. If multiple references are cited at the same location, their numbers should be separated by commas, e.g., [1,3,5]. If the cited reference numbers are consecutive, they should be collapsed, e.g., [1-3,5]. Zotero also renders in-text citations in this manner.
However, in Typst, the collapsing behavior does not work as expected. When citing multiple consecutive references at the same location, Typst displays them as [1,3] instead of the expected [1-3]. Similarly, when citing references 1, 2, 3, and 5 at the same location, Typst renders them as [1,3,5] instead of the expected [1-3,5].
1 - @TestBook_1
2 - @TestBook_2
3 - @TestBook_3
4 - @TestBook_4
5 - @TestBook_5
Test 1: Expected #super[[1-3,5]] Actual @TestBook_1@TestBook_2@TestBook_3@TestBook_5
Test 2: Expected #super[[1,3,5]] Actual @TestBook_1@TestBook_3@TestBook_5
Test 3: Expected #super[[1-3]] Actual @TestBook_1@TestBook_2@TestBook_3#bibliography("ref.bib", style: "gb-7714-2015-numeric")
Through testing, I found that in Typst/hayagriva the after-collapse-delimiter attribute in the CSL file controls the delimiter used for collapsing consecutive numbers. Changing after-collapse-delimiter="," to after-collapse-delimiter="-" results in the expected behavior, displaying [1-3,5].
Specifies the cite delimiter to be used after a collapsed cite group.
Based on the example provided in the documentation, I think this attribute should control the comma (,) in [1-3,5], not the hyphen (-). I have tested other numeric citation styles with the collapse attribute and observed similar issues.
I kindly request guidance on whether this behavior is intended or if there is a potential issue with the collapsing implementation in Typst/hayagriva.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I have encountered an issue with the collapsing behavior of consecutive citation numbers in in-text citations when using the
bibliography
function in Typst. Using the citation style"gb-7714-2015-numeric"
, the relevant CSL code for citation rendering is as follows:According to this style, in-text citations should be rendered as superscript numbers enclosed in square brackets, e.g.,
[1]
. If multiple references are cited at the same location, their numbers should be separated by commas, e.g.,[1,3,5]
. If the cited reference numbers are consecutive, they should be collapsed, e.g.,[1-3,5]
. Zotero also renders in-text citations in this manner.However, in Typst, the collapsing behavior does not work as expected. When citing multiple consecutive references at the same location, Typst displays them as
[1,3]
instead of the expected[1-3]
. Similarly, when citing references 1, 2, 3, and 5 at the same location, Typst renders them as[1,3,5]
instead of the expected[1-3,5]
.Through testing, I found that in Typst/hayagriva the
after-collapse-delimiter
attribute in the CSL file controls the delimiter used for collapsing consecutive numbers. Changingafter-collapse-delimiter=","
toafter-collapse-delimiter="-"
results in the expected behavior, displaying[1-3,5]
.However, according to the CSL 1.0.2 documentation - Cite Collapsing, the
after-collapse-delimiter
attribute is described as:Based on the example provided in the documentation, I think this attribute should control the comma (
,
) in[1-3,5]
, not the hyphen (-
). I have tested other numeric citation styles with thecollapse
attribute and observed similar issues.I kindly request guidance on whether this behavior is intended or if there is a potential issue with the collapsing implementation in Typst/hayagriva.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: