Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add support for WFC3/IR time-dependent IMPHTTAB to calwf3 #588

Open
astromariarosa opened this issue Aug 16, 2023 · 11 comments
Open

Add support for WFC3/IR time-dependent IMPHTTAB to calwf3 #588

astromariarosa opened this issue Aug 16, 2023 · 11 comments

Comments

@astromariarosa
Copy link

calwf3 was updated in 2020 to enable time-dependent photometry for the WFC3/UVIS detector (i.e. issue #451). We would like to enact the same changes for the WFC3/IR detector by fall 2023, hopefully end of September. These are high-priority changes, is that timeframe possible? We can provide a dummy reference file for testing within the next two weeks.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@astromariarosa I know about this work from some email discussion with Annalisa. As such, this work is on my official schedule, but it is unlikely to be done by the end of September 2023. I have some other high priority work which I need to address first, particularly since I did not expect this new IR calibration reference file until the September/October timeframe.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@astromariarosa To be clear, there is ACS work which has higher priority than this work. The WFC3 IR TVB work still has not been defined or passed to me for any action.

@acalamid
Copy link

@mdlpstsci No problem. We still have to finalize the sensitivity slopes and re-calculate the inverse sensitivity values and we won't have these until the end of September.
I was wondering if you managed to do some preliminary testing related to the ticket HLA-1030.
Thanks,
Annalisa

@astromariarosa
Copy link
Author

We have a dummy IMPHTTAB file ready for you, for whenever you get the time to work on this. It is located at /grp/hst/wfc3v/marinelli/ir_phot/imphttab/ir_imphttab_td.fits.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@acalamid @astromariarosa
FYI - I am taking a look at your dummy IMPHTTAB file.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@acalamid @astromariarosa
I have made the changes to calwf3 and compiled the code on the Linux systems for your testing. You can access the modified calwf3 executable as:

/home/mdelapena/imphot_repos/hstcal/_build/pkg/wfc3/calwf3.e

You can test that you have the updated version:

/home/mdelapena/imphot_repos/hstcal/_build/pkg/wfc3/calwf3.e --version

and you should see 3.7.2. If have any problems accessing this executable, please let me know. Of course, if you have any issues/complaints/questions, you should let me know too!

When comparing the FLT file as produced by the new version (3.7.2) to an older version, you will see:

(rc5_caldp_infrastructure) bash-4.2$ fitsdiff NEWOUT/*flt.fits OLDOUT/
 fitsdiff: 6.0.0
 a: /home/mdelapena/WFC3/IMPHTTAB/NEWOUT/ib4606clq_flt.fits
 b: /home/mdelapena/WFC3/IMPHTTAB/OLDOUT/ib4606clq_flt.fits
 Maximum number of different data values to be reported: 10
 Relative tolerance: 0.0, Absolute tolerance: 0.0
Primary HDU:
   Headers contain differences:
     Keyword CAL_VER  has different values:
        a> 3.7.2 (Apr-15-2024)
        b> 3.7.1 (Oct-18-2023)
     Keyword HISTORY [28] has different values:
        a>   reference table ir_imphttab_td.fits
        b>   reference table iref$4af1533ai_imp.fits
     Keyword HISTORY [30] has different values:
        a>     2023 Time-dependent Inverse Sensitivity
        b>     photometry keywords reference file---------------------------------
     Keyword IMPHTTAB has different values:
        a> ir_imphttab_td.fits
        b> iref$4af1533ai_imp.fits
     Keyword PHOTFLAM has different values:
        a> 1.5571101e-20
        b> 1.5318e-20
     Keyword PHOTFNU  has different values:
        a> 6.9102363e-08
        b> 6.7979137e-08
     Keyword PHOTMODE has different values:
        a> WFC3 IR F110W MJD#55611.0931
        b> WFC3 IR F110W

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

Git PR#612 was merged onto main (HLA-1036). Any changes requested by WFC3 team will be charged against a new JIRA HLA ticket.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

For my reference...
(Mac)
My test directory is /Users/mdelapena/HSTCAL/IMPHTTAB/IR.
Git branch is ir_imphot (repos/hstcal)
(Linux)
My test directory is /home/mdelapena/WFC3/IMPHTTAB.
Git branch is linux_ir_imphot (imphot_repos/hstcal/)

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@astromariarosa @acalamid
This is just a reminder that you can test the updated algorithm as stated in my comment from April. We are about to release an infrastructure build. This means that the team will start thinking about the contents for the next build. If you are happy with the results or want some changes, this would be a good time to let me know. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to ask.

@mdlpstsci
Copy link
Contributor

@starivera
Adding Isabel so she can follow-up on this issue.

@astromariarosa
Copy link
Author

@mdlpstsci Thanks for the nudge Michele!

@st-apidgeon will be testing the updated executable. We will keep you in the loop regarding our progress and any issues we encounter.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants