Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

pmemcheck incosistently reporting issues w.r.t. stores outside of transactions #47

Open
pbalcer opened this issue Sep 20, 2017 · 0 comments
Labels

Comments

@pbalcer
Copy link
Member

pbalcer commented Sep 20, 2017

This code:

	VALGRIND_REMOVE_FROM_TX(run, runsize);

	pmemops_persist(&heap->p_ops, run->bitmap, sizeof(run->bitmap));

	struct chunk_header run_data_hdr;
	run_data_hdr.type = CHUNK_TYPE_RUN_DATA;
	run_data_hdr.flags = 0;

	struct chunk_header *data_hdr;
	for (unsigned i = 1; i < m->size_idx; ++i) {
		data_hdr = &z->chunk_headers[m->chunk_id + i];
		VALGRIND_DO_MAKE_MEM_UNDEFINED(data_hdr, sizeof(*data_hdr));
		VALGRIND_ADD_TO_TX(data_hdr, sizeof(*data_hdr));
		run_data_hdr.size_idx = i;
		*data_hdr = run_data_hdr;
		VALGRIND_REMOVE_FROM_TX(data_hdr, sizeof(*data_hdr));
	}
	pmemops_persist(&heap->p_ops,
		&z->chunk_headers[m->chunk_id + 1],
		sizeof(struct chunk_header) * (m->size_idx - 1));

	struct chunk_header *hdr = &z->chunk_headers[m->chunk_id];
	ASSERT(hdr->type == CHUNK_TYPE_FREE);

	VALGRIND_ADD_TO_TX(hdr, sizeof(*hdr));
	struct chunk_header run_hdr;
	run_hdr.size_idx = hdr->size_idx;
	run_hdr.type = CHUNK_TYPE_RUN;
	run_hdr.flags = header_type_to_flag[c->header_type];
	*hdr = run_hdr;
	VALGRIND_REMOVE_FROM_TX(hdr, sizeof(*hdr));

*data_hdr = run_data_hdr; is the problematic assignment.

Produces the following issue:


==28070== Number of stores made without adding to transaction: 14
==28070== Stores made without adding to transactions:
==28070== [0]    at 0x4C471F7: heap_run_init (heap.c:393)
==28070==    by 0x4C47AFE: heap_create_run (heap.c:517)
==28070==    by 0x4C48A01: heap_ensure_run_bucket_filled (heap.c:825)
==28070==    by 0x4C48DF0: heap_get_bestfit_block (heap.c:909)
==28070==    by 0x4C5AD50: palloc_operation (palloc.c:211)
==28070==    by 0x4C5C1D0: pmalloc_operation (pmalloc.c:116)
==28070==    by 0x4C5C3F7: pmalloc_construct (pmalloc.c:166)
==28070==    by 0x4C648E1: tx_alloc_common (tx.c:1010)
==28070==    by 0x4C679B1: pmemobj_tx_alloc (tx.c:1961)
==28070==    by 0x404F2B: sc8_verify_abort (obj_convert.c:467)
==28070==    by 0x405A67: main (obj_convert.c:594)
==28070== 	Address: 0x6102490	size: 16

But only sometimes (can't reproduce this reliably outside of this specific case: pmem/pmdk#2242).
Regardless of anything else, the report is false, because the store is clearly added to the transaction.

Wrapping the entire code section in a add_to_tx, that encompasses the entire modifiable area, fixes the problem.

@wlemkows wlemkows added the bug label Mar 13, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants