Mark comments as resolved

[jeroenvisser101]

It would be nice if we could have an option to mark comments on PRs as resolved so they'd be collapsed or dimmed.

[jeroenvisser101]

This is done!

[AmatanHead]

Sorry to bring this up. Maybe I'm missing something.
This issue is closed but I don't see how can I mark comments as resolved...

[fritzo]

The only options on the github gui are 'add a reaction', 'change', and 'delete'. There is no 'resolve'.

[jeroenvisser101]

Since only reviews can be marked as resolved, I guess this is still pending.

[ourownstory]

Yes, this simple feature would greatly speed up my workflow when resolving comments!

[aspiers]

As with many other issues in this repository, this is a duplicate of an issue already filed in isaacs/github:

• Mark an conversation on a diff as resolved · Issue #251 · isaacs/github

[koenpunt]

Comments on issues can be marked as resolved as of not too long ago

[aspiers]

@koenpunt commented on 1 Aug 2018, 21:00 BST:

Comments on issues can be marked as resolved as of not too long ago

True but this is missing lots more details, which are covered in the issue of which this is a duplicate.

IMHO this is another example of many that this repository is damaging the GitHub community by unnecessarily fragmenting it. I have tried to help fix that but unfortunately my PR has been ignored.

[mgalgs]

In the meantime, Revieable.io can do this and a bunch of other neat tricks... (I am not affiliated with Reviewable other than being a very happy user.)

[jeroenvisser101]

I'm going to close this as I don't think GitHub will (in the short term) be adding this and because the current features already allow more then when this was opened. Should anyone have a different opinion, they can raise their own issue.

[riyadshauk]

What's the recommended etiquette to follow when closing an issue when we want to mark it as resolved? For instance, if it were a bug, should I remove the label "bug" when it's resolved?