Planet bala and bhava balas are not matching

[AbhayVivek]

I have tried to compare the values of all the planetary balas and bhava balas with values generated by astrosage.com
and only a few of them are matching

1. dig bala
2. Uchcha Bala
3. Ojhayugmarasiamsa Bala
4. Drekkana Bala
5. Nathonnatha Bala

Rest all the balas are not matching, the values generated by vedastro might be right,
If you have verified those values, could you please share the software screenshot of all balas (of any time)

[sengiv]

verified using text book bv raman, we can verify again no problem but first I need a screenshot of the Astro sage data that you used to compare

[sengiv]

Thank you for your quick reply, we'll check on this and report back

[sengiv]

@AbhayVivek if possible please post the wrong results that are coming out from the API with the corresponding URL so I can verify it with the Astro sage screenshot that you gave above

[sengiv]

Awesome work 👏 👌

[sengiv]

Please give link to the app you used to verify

[sengiv]

Finally we can mark this issue as resolved 😃

Before explain solution below are some facts to help understand what is going on.

FACTS:

• 2 x seperate "ancient" texts exist in English translation online that talk calculation steps for "Shadbala"
  • Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra
  • Phaladeepika
• each text "known" text above has different method for each sub-bala calculation (go read the Sanskrit translation yourself, you'll see difference in math order and algorithm, but both use the word shadbala)
• more unknown text still in "Hindi" or "Sanskrit" being used by astrosage? does astrosage say which one of the tens of book they use?

QUESTION:

• So which calculation to use? Which text is lying and which is telling truth?

ANSWER :

Both are correct. Only "sub-bala" will miss, because the math algorithm varies,
but once all the points have been totaled --> SHADBALA. Values from astrosage & vedastro match >80%, error rate <20%.
Meaning, the order of the strengths does not change even if small values change underneath.

TEST SCREENSHOTS

https://vedastroapi.azurewebsites.net/api/Calculate/AllPlanetStrength/Location/Delhi,India/Time/01:30/14/02/2024/+05:30

[sengiv]

@AbhayVivek please don't take my answer as final, if you can find a better answer, or further issue to proof that error is above >20%, then I will dig deeper, because real problem. Else 20% mismatch rate is very good in my opinion. Hence will mark as resolved upon your confirmation. 🙏