Adding the domains to the Public Suffix List

[aeternesatiatus]

I suggest you add cluster.ws and wip.la to the Public Suffix List, in the likes of other similar free subdomain services like eu.org and js.org.

This would help against supercookies and other issues (i.e. per-domain rate limits)

[politician]

I did try but it was rejected. I plan to retry later, if you or anybody else has more arguments to support our case, please comment here, I'll use this as a reference.

[BastelPichi]

Me sad 👎 lol
Please retry at some point. Also somehow therese seams to be a way to use subdomains?! Allthough that pretty much what I tried before...
https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/360026440252-Understanding-Subdomain-Support#h_39a346bb-4726-4f69-969e-016fbacbb2c0

[aeternesatiatus]

Sorry for such a late reply

I suppose, you could argue that eu.org, js.org are similar free subdomain services that have been previously accepted to the PSL @politician

Not to mention all these corporate domains that were included to the PSL as well.

[ririko5834]

yeah, if it was on PSL, then I could use it with cloudflare DNS

[aeternesatiatus]

Perhaps, but these are not acceptable reasons the PSL maintainers. As such, the point is that these domains are for a free subdomain service, whose users are mutually untrusted parties and as a de facto public suffix, it should be added to prevent cross-subdomain security issues.

While it may matter to you that you want to use LE or Cloudflare, to the eye of the PSL maintainers it is just a way to circumvent third-party limits if you mention these reasons.

You want to insist on the fact that it is a free subdomain service for independent users who are mutually-untrusting and that it is a free and public service and therefore a de facto public suffix that should be added to the PSL. You may also remind PSL maintainers that other free subdomain services are listed, and often also non-public domains are also added to the PSL.

[IncognitoTGT]

Me sad 👎 lol Please retry at some point. Also somehow therese seams to be a way to use subdomains?! Allthough that pretty much what I tried before... https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/360026440252-Understanding-Subdomain-Support#h_39a346bb-4726-4f69-969e-016fbacbb2c0

You have to pay for enterprise though

[IncognitoTGT]

Tell that the domain is used exclusively for subdomains, and adding it to the PSL would make it work like a normal subdomain

[IncognitoTGT]

Also since it prevents the entire domain from getting flagged by Safe Browsing, which happened