[feature] Prop for setting 2nd param of springPositions.set()

[jfrancos]

Describe the feature
I'd like to be able to set the 2nd param of springPositions.set(), so I can adjust animations on the fly.

Explain it's value / reasoning
I'd like to remove the animation effect in the case where a user is continuously sliding the nub.

Additional context
It's a very small adjustment to the code, which I've done in a fork. I've tried it out, and it does what I want. Obvs happy to submit a PR, but thought I'd open an issue for it first (I haven't contributed much to open source projects so I'm not sure what is customary here?)

[jfrancos]

This is what I'm then doing in my own code, to create the effect I'm looking for:

<script>
...
  const handleTouchEnd = () => {
    setSpringOptions = undefined;
    removeEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
    addEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
  };

  const handleTouchMove = () => {
    setSpringOptions = { hard: true };
    removeEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
    addEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
  };

  onMount(() => addEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove));
  onDestroy(() => {
    removeEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
    removeEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
  });
...
</script>

[simeydotme]

thanks @jfrancos ..

I kind of understand your desired effect, not sure fully how to approach this to be honest... is it not OK for you to dampen spring uniformly? What's the need for two effects in different contexts?

(p.s thanks for the two issues, I will get to the other one as soon a I can, I have a branch for it but I found an issue which would take me much more to test and investigate, 🙏 )

[jfrancos]

Hi @simeydotme,

The desire for changing the effect is wanting it to snap to each value, while a user is sliding it through the different values. With the animation in effect, it kind of glides through the values as the user is sliding their finger, rather than stopping at each one.

But, I'd still like the animated effect when the handle is moving over longer distances.

As for how to approach it ... this very tiny change to src/RangeSlider.svelte does the trick. If you're okay with it, I can open a PR.

[simeydotme]

yeh, I can see the change and how it works... but my gripe is how it's encouraging this;

const handleTouchEnd = () => {
    setSpringOptions = undefined;
    removeEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
    addEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
  };

  const handleTouchMove = () => {
    setSpringOptions = { hard: true };
    removeEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
    addEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
  };

  onMount(() => addEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove));
  onDestroy(() => {
    removeEventListener("touchmove", handleTouchMove);
    removeEventListener("touchend", handleTouchEnd);
  });

which I believe to be a code smell.
(and in fact, you should probably consider using these events instead!)

---

I feel like it should probably be a boolean option where I can optimise the toggling of the spring internally... but then I feel like why not just make it default behaviour? Is there any value to having the handle be springy while being dragged? The only downside is it's an aesthetically change

[jfrancos]

(and in fact, you should probably consider using these events instead!)

That would be nice, except that those custom events don't reveal what the underlying event is, so I don't think there'd be a way to differentiate between moving between two adjacent positions via press vs drag.

That said, if you want to add this behavior as an option, that would be really cool and I could delete a few lines of code! :)

Is there any value to having the handle be springy while being dragged?

I personally think it feels unnatural for it to be springy while dragged, but I see how others may want this behavior.

[jfrancos]

Also fwiw, I've updated my code to

const handleTouchEnd = () => {
  setSpringOptions = undefined;
};

const handleTouchMove = () => {
  setSpringOptions = { hard: true };
};

...
<div
  on:touchmove={handleTouchMove}
  on:touchend={handleTouchEnd}
>
  <RangeSlider ... />
</div>

[simeydotme]

thanks for the discussion @jfrancos , al very valuable :)
I will try to approach this in the coming weeks, I might have to push a minor version and caveat it has aesthetic changes.